Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
63 lines (52 loc) · 9.24 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

63 lines (52 loc) · 9.24 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for python-telegram-bot/python-telegram-bot

Attack Surface: Command Injection via User Input

  • Description: Attackers inject malicious system commands within user-provided text messages, which are then executed by the bot's application.
  • Python-Telegram-Bot Contribution: The library provides straightforward mechanisms to receive and process user messages (updater.dispatcher.add_handler, message.text). This ease of access to user input directly contributes to the attack surface if developers don't implement proper input sanitization before using the input in system commands.
  • Example: A bot is designed to execute shell commands based on user input. A user sends the message: /run command ls -l ; rm -rf /. If the bot directly executes this string without sanitization, it will list files and then attempt to delete the entire filesystem.
  • Impact: Full system compromise, data loss, denial of service, unauthorized access.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Input Sanitization: Thoroughly validate and sanitize all user input before using it in system commands or any potentially dangerous operations. Employ whitelisting of allowed characters or commands instead of relying on blacklisting.
    • Avoid System Command Execution: Minimize or eliminate the execution of system commands based on user input. Utilize Python libraries or built-in functions to achieve the desired functionality instead of resorting to shell commands.
    • Principle of Least Privilege: Run the bot application with the minimum necessary privileges to limit the potential damage from command injection.

Attack Surface: Denial of Service (DoS) via Large/Crafted Messages

  • Description: Attackers send excessively large or specially crafted messages to overwhelm the bot's resources, causing it to become unresponsive or crash.
  • Python-Telegram-Bot Contribution: The library is designed to handle messages of varying sizes as part of its core functionality. If the bot application logic built using python-telegram-bot lacks safeguards against resource exhaustion when processing unusually large or complex messages, it becomes vulnerable to DoS attacks.
  • Example: An attacker sends a message containing an extremely long string or a deeply nested JSON structure (if the bot parses message entities in a complex way). The bot attempts to process this message, consuming excessive memory or CPU, leading to slow response times or complete failure.
  • Impact: Bot unavailability, service disruption, resource exhaustion on the hosting server.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Input Validation and Limits: Implement limits on the size and complexity of messages processed by the bot. Reject messages that exceed these predefined limits.
    • Resource Monitoring and Rate Limiting: Monitor the bot's resource usage (CPU, memory). Implement rate limiting to prevent excessive requests from a single user or source, mitigating DoS attempts.
    • Asynchronous Processing: Utilize asynchronous task queues (like Celery or Redis Queue) to handle message processing. This prevents blocking the main bot thread and enhances resilience to DoS attacks by distributing the processing load.

Attack Surface: Callback Query Data Manipulation

  • Description: Attackers tamper with callback data associated with inline keyboard buttons to manipulate bot behavior or gain unauthorized access to sensitive actions.
  • Python-Telegram-Bot Contribution: The library provides the functionality to create and handle inline keyboards and callback queries. Developers define callback data associated with buttons, and if this data is not properly secured, it becomes a manipulation point.
  • Example: An inline keyboard button is designed to confirm a user's action with callback data like action=confirm,user_id=123. An attacker intercepts the callback query and modifies user_id to 456, potentially allowing them to perform actions intended for another user. This could lead to unauthorized modifications or access.
  • Impact: Unauthorized actions, data manipulation, privilege escalation, potentially leading to significant security breaches depending on the actions controlled by callbacks.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Cryptographic Signing of Callback Data: Sign callback data using a secret key before sending it to the user. Upon receiving a callback query, verify the signature on the server-side to ensure data integrity and prevent tampering.
    • Server-Side Session Management: Instead of embedding sensitive data directly within callback data, use a server-side session to store the state associated with the interaction. The callback data can then contain only a session identifier, reducing the attack surface for data manipulation.
    • Stateless Callbacks with Robust Validation: If stateless callbacks are necessary, employ a secure, verifiable encoding scheme for the data and rigorously validate it on the server-side to ensure its integrity and prevent malicious modifications.

Attack Surface: Exposure of Telegram Bot Token

  • Description: The Telegram Bot API token, which grants complete control over the bot, is exposed to unauthorized parties.
  • Python-Telegram-Bot Contribution: The python-telegram-bot library fundamentally requires the bot token to initialize the Bot object and interact with the Telegram API. Improper handling of this token during development, deployment, or storage directly leads to a critical vulnerability.
  • Example: The bot token is hardcoded directly in the Python script and accidentally committed to a public GitHub repository. An attacker discovers the token and gains full control over the bot, enabling them to send messages, access data, and potentially cause significant harm.
  • Impact: Complete bot compromise, unauthorized access to bot functionalities and potentially associated data, impersonation, and the ability to perform malicious actions through the bot.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Environment Variables: Store the bot token as an environment variable and access it using os.environ.get('BOT_TOKEN'). This practice effectively separates the token from the codebase, preventing accidental exposure in version control.
    • Secure Configuration Management: Utilize secure configuration management tools (such as HashiCorp Vault, AWS Secrets Manager, or similar services) to securely store and manage the bot token. These tools offer encryption, access control, and auditing capabilities.
    • Avoid Hardcoding and Version Control: Absolutely avoid hardcoding the token directly in the code or configuration files that are committed to version control systems.
    • Restrict Access to Configuration: Implement strict access controls to configuration files and environment variables containing the token, limiting access to only authorized personnel and processes.

Attack Surface: Unsecured Webhook Endpoint (If using Webhooks)

  • Description: When configured to use webhooks, if the endpoint receiving Telegram updates is not secured with HTTPS, it becomes vulnerable to eavesdropping and Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) attacks.
  • Python-Telegram-Bot Contribution: The library provides functionality to set up webhooks (updater.start_webhook). While it strongly encourages HTTPS, misconfiguration or a failure to enforce HTTPS for the webhook endpoint creates a significant security vulnerability.
  • Example: A bot is configured with a webhook URL using http://example.com/webhook. An attacker positioned on the network path between Telegram and the bot server can intercept webhook requests sent by Telegram to this HTTP endpoint. This allows them to read message content, potentially inject malicious updates, or impersonate Telegram.
  • Impact: Data interception, message manipulation, unauthorized access to bot communications, potential bot compromise through injected updates.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Enforce HTTPS: Always use HTTPS for the webhook URL (https://example.com/webhook). Obtain a valid SSL/TLS certificate from a trusted Certificate Authority for your domain to enable secure communication.
    • Webhook Verification (Telegram's Secret Token): Utilize Telegram's built-in webhook verification mechanism by configuring and checking the X-Telegram-Bot-Api-Secret-Token header in your webhook handler. This ensures that incoming requests are genuinely originating from Telegram and not from malicious sources.
    • Firewall and Network Security: Implement firewall rules to restrict access to the webhook endpoint, ideally allowing only traffic originating from Telegram's known IP address ranges. This further reduces the attack surface and prevents unauthorized access to the webhook receiver.