Okay, let's create a design document for the Ray project, focusing on aspects relevant to threat modeling.

BUSINESS POSTURE

Ray is a unified framework for scaling AI and Python applications. It's used across various industries, from startups to large enterprises, but its core value proposition centers around enabling rapid development and deployment of computationally intensive workloads. This suggests a business posture that prioritizes:

Priorities:
- Scalability: The ability to handle rapidly growing workloads is paramount.
- Performance: Minimizing latency and maximizing throughput are critical for AI applications.
- Ease of Use: Simplifying the development and deployment of distributed applications is a key selling point.
- Flexibility: Supporting a wide range of AI frameworks and libraries is essential.
- Cost-Effectiveness: Optimizing resource utilization to reduce operational costs is important, especially at scale.
- Reliability: Ensuring the system operates correctly and recovers from failures is crucial for production deployments.
Goals:
- Become the leading platform for scaling AI and Python applications.
- Attract a large and active community of users and contributors.
- Enable the development of cutting-edge AI applications.
- Provide a robust and reliable platform for production deployments.
Business Risks:
- Data Corruption/Loss: Given the focus on data-intensive workloads, corruption or loss of data during processing is a major risk. This could stem from software bugs, hardware failures, or malicious attacks.
- Unauthorized Access: Sensitive data or models could be exposed if the system is compromised. This includes both external attacks and insider threats.
- Denial of Service (DoS): The distributed nature of Ray makes it a potential target for DoS attacks, which could disrupt critical applications.
- Resource Exhaustion: Malicious or unintentional workloads could consume excessive resources, leading to performance degradation or cost overruns.
- Supply Chain Vulnerabilities: Dependencies on third-party libraries or components could introduce vulnerabilities.
- Compliance Violations: Depending on the specific use case, failure to comply with relevant data privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR, CCPA) could result in significant penalties.
- Intellectual Property Theft: The algorithms and models deployed on Ray may represent valuable intellectual property that needs protection.

SECURITY POSTURE

Based on the GitHub repository and general knowledge of distributed systems, here's an assessment of Ray's security posture:

Existing Security Controls:
- security control: Authentication: Ray supports authentication using tokens and TLS certificates. (See Ray documentation and code related to authentication).
- security control: Authorization: Ray provides role-based access control (RBAC) to manage permissions for different users and services. (See Ray documentation and code related to RBAC).
- security control: Encryption in Transit: Communication between Ray nodes can be encrypted using TLS. (See Ray documentation and configuration options for TLS).
- security control: Input Validation: Ray performs some input validation to prevent common attacks, such as injection vulnerabilities. (See Ray code related to data serialization and deserialization).
- security control: Dependency Management: Ray uses established package managers (pip, conda) to manage dependencies, allowing for vulnerability scanning.
- security control: Regular Security Audits: The Ray project undergoes periodic security reviews and penetration testing. (See Ray documentation and community discussions).
- security control: Documentation: Ray provides extensive documentation, including security best practices.
Accepted Risks:
- accepted risk: Complexity of Distributed Systems: The inherent complexity of distributed systems introduces a larger attack surface and makes it challenging to guarantee complete security.
- accepted risk: Reliance on Third-Party Libraries: Ray depends on numerous third-party libraries, each with its own potential vulnerabilities.
- accepted risk: Performance Trade-offs: Some security measures (e.g., fine-grained access control) can impact performance, requiring careful balancing.
- accepted risk: User Misconfiguration: Ray offers many configuration options, and incorrect settings can create security vulnerabilities.
Recommended Security Controls:
- Data at Rest Encryption: Implement encryption for data stored on persistent storage (e.g., object stores, databases) used by Ray.
- Enhanced Input Sanitization: Strengthen input validation to handle a wider range of potentially malicious inputs, especially in custom code executed within Ray tasks.
- Network Segmentation: Isolate Ray clusters from the public internet and other internal networks using firewalls and network policies.
- Intrusion Detection System (IDS): Deploy an IDS to monitor network traffic and system activity for suspicious behavior.
- Regular Vulnerability Scanning: Automate vulnerability scanning of Ray deployments and dependencies.
- Security Hardening Guides: Provide detailed security hardening guides for different deployment environments (e.g., Kubernetes, cloud providers).
- Supply Chain Security Measures: Implement measures to verify the integrity of Ray's dependencies and prevent supply chain attacks (e.g., software signing, SBOMs).
Security Requirements:
- Authentication:
  - All communication between Ray components and external clients must be authenticated.
  - Support for strong authentication mechanisms (e.g., multi-factor authentication) should be considered.
  - Authentication credentials must be securely stored and managed.
- Authorization:
  - Access to Ray resources (e.g., tasks, objects, actors) must be controlled based on the principle of least privilege.
  - RBAC should be granular enough to enforce fine-grained access control policies.
  - Audit logs should record all authorization decisions.
- Input Validation:
  - All inputs to Ray tasks and actors must be validated to prevent injection attacks and other vulnerabilities.
  - Input validation should be performed on both the client and server sides.
  - A whitelist approach to input validation is preferred over a blacklist approach.
- Cryptography:
  - All sensitive data transmitted between Ray components or stored at rest must be encrypted.
  - Strong cryptographic algorithms and key management practices must be used.
  - Regularly review and update cryptographic configurations to address emerging threats.

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

graph LR
    subgraph Ray Ecosystem
        User["User"]
        RayCluster["Ray Cluster"]
        ExternalServices["External Services (e.g., Cloud Storage, Databases)"]
        MonitoringTools["Monitoring Tools"]
    end

    User -- "Submits tasks, interacts with results" --> RayCluster
    RayCluster -- "Accesses data, performs computations" --> ExternalServices
    RayCluster -- "Provides metrics, logs" --> MonitoringTools

Loading

Elements Description:
- User:
  - Name: User
  - Type: Person
  - Description: A person who interacts with the Ray cluster, submitting tasks, monitoring progress, and retrieving results.
  - Responsibilities: Submitting tasks, managing jobs, accessing results, configuring the Ray client.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization (RBAC).
- Ray Cluster:
  - Name: Ray Cluster
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: The core Ray system, consisting of a head node and multiple worker nodes.
  - Responsibilities: Scheduling tasks, managing resources, executing computations, storing objects.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization (RBAC), encryption in transit, input validation.
- External Services:
  - Name: External Services
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: External services that Ray interacts with, such as cloud storage, databases, and other APIs.
  - Responsibilities: Providing data storage, database access, and other external functionalities.
  - Security controls: Dependent on the specific service (e.g., AWS IAM, database credentials).
- Monitoring Tools:
  - Name: Monitoring Tools
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: Tools used to monitor the performance and health of the Ray cluster.
  - Responsibilities: Collecting metrics, visualizing data, alerting on anomalies.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization (access control for monitoring dashboards).

C4 CONTAINER

graph LR
    subgraph Ray Cluster
        HeadNode["Head Node"]
        WorkerNode1["Worker Node 1"]
        WorkerNode2["Worker Node 2"]
        WorkerNodeN["Worker Node N"]

        subgraph Head Node
            GlobalControlStore["Global Control Store (GCS)"]
            RayletHead["Raylet (Head)"]
            ObjectStoreHead["Object Store (Head)"]
        end

        subgraph Worker Node
            RayletWorker["Raylet (Worker)"]
            ObjectStoreWorker["Object Store (Worker)"]
            WorkerProcess["Worker Process(es)"]
        end
    end
    
    HeadNode -- "Manages cluster state" --> WorkerNode1
    HeadNode -- "Manages cluster state" --> WorkerNode2
    HeadNode -- "Manages cluster state" --> WorkerNodeN
    WorkerNode1 -- "Inter-node communication" <--> WorkerNode2
    WorkerNode1 -- "Inter-node communication" <--> WorkerNodeN
    WorkerNode2 -- "Inter-node communication" <--> WorkerNodeN

Loading

Elements Description:
- Head Node:
  - Name: Head Node
  - Type: Container
  - Description: The central node in the Ray cluster, responsible for cluster management.
  - Responsibilities: Scheduling tasks, managing resources, storing cluster metadata.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization (RBAC), encryption in transit, input validation.
- Global Control Store (GCS):
  - Name: Global Control Store (GCS)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: A key-value store that stores cluster metadata and state.
  - Responsibilities: Storing information about tasks, objects, actors, and nodes.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization, encryption (if persistent storage is used).
- Raylet (Head):
  - Name: Raylet (Head)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: The main process on the head node, responsible for scheduling and resource management.
  - Responsibilities: Scheduling tasks, managing resources, communicating with worker nodes.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization, input validation.
- Object Store (Head):
  - Name: Object Store (Head)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: Stores immutable objects that are shared between tasks and actors.
  - Responsibilities: Storing and retrieving objects, managing object references.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization, encryption (if persistent storage is used).
- Worker Node:
  - Name: Worker Node
  - Type: Container
  - Description: A node in the Ray cluster that executes tasks and stores objects.
  - Responsibilities: Executing tasks, storing objects, communicating with the head node and other worker nodes.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization, encryption in transit, input validation.
- Raylet (Worker):
  - Name: Raylet (Worker)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: The main process on a worker node, responsible for task execution and resource management.
  - Responsibilities: Executing tasks, managing resources, communicating with the head node and other worker nodes.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization, input validation.
- Object Store (Worker):
  - Name: Object Store (Worker)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: Stores immutable objects that are shared between tasks and actors.
  - Responsibilities: Storing and retrieving objects, managing object references.
  - Security controls: Authentication, authorization, encryption (if persistent storage is used).
- Worker Process(es):
  - Name: Worker Process(es)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: Processes that execute Ray tasks and actors.
  - Responsibilities: Executing Python code, interacting with the object store.
  - Security controls: Input validation, sandboxing (if applicable).

DEPLOYMENT

Ray can be deployed in various environments, including:

Local Machine: For development and testing.
Cluster of Machines: Using Ray's built-in cluster launcher or manual configuration.
Kubernetes: Using the Ray Kubernetes operator or KubeRay.
Cloud Providers (AWS, GCP, Azure): Leveraging cloud-specific services (e.g., EC2, GCE, AKS, EKS, GKE).

We'll describe the Kubernetes deployment using KubeRay, as it's a common and recommended approach for production deployments.

graph LR
    subgraph Kubernetes Cluster
        subgraph Ray Cluster Namespace
            RayHeadPod["Ray Head Pod"]
            RayWorkerPod1["Ray Worker Pod 1"]
            RayWorkerPodN["Ray Worker Pod N"]
            K8sService["Kubernetes Service"]
        end
        Ingress["Ingress Controller"]
        PersistentVolume["Persistent Volume (Optional)"]
    end

    User -- "kubectl, Ray Client" --> Ingress
    Ingress -- "Routes traffic" --> K8sService
    K8sService -- "Load balances" --> RayHeadPod
    RayHeadPod -- "Manages cluster" --> RayWorkerPod1
    RayHeadPod -- "Manages cluster" --> RayWorkerPodN
    RayWorkerPod1 -- "Inter-pod communication" <--> RayWorkerPodN
    RayHeadPod -- "Accesses storage" --> PersistentVolume
    RayWorkerPod1 -- "Accesses storage" --> PersistentVolume
    RayWorkerPodN -- "Accesses storage" --> PersistentVolume

Loading

Elements Description:
- Kubernetes Cluster:
  - Name: Kubernetes Cluster
  - Type: Deployment Environment
  - Description: The Kubernetes cluster where Ray is deployed.
  - Responsibilities: Orchestrating containers, managing resources, providing networking.
  - Security controls: Kubernetes RBAC, network policies, pod security policies.
- Ray Cluster Namespace:
  - Name: Ray Cluster Namespace
  - Type: Logical Grouping
  - Description: A Kubernetes namespace dedicated to the Ray cluster.
  - Responsibilities: Isolating Ray resources from other applications.
  - Security controls: Kubernetes namespace isolation.
- Ray Head Pod:
  - Name: Ray Head Pod
  - Type: Pod
  - Description: The Kubernetes pod running the Ray head node.
  - Responsibilities: Running the Ray head node processes (GCS, Raylet, Object Store).
  - Security controls: Kubernetes pod security context, network policies.
- Ray Worker Pod 1/N:
  - Name: Ray Worker Pod 1/N
  - Type: Pod
  - Description: Kubernetes pods running Ray worker nodes.
  - Responsibilities: Running the Ray worker node processes (Raylet, Object Store, Worker Processes).
  - Security controls: Kubernetes pod security context, network policies.
- Kubernetes Service:
  - Name: Kubernetes Service
  - Type: Service
  - Description: A Kubernetes service that exposes the Ray head node.
  - Responsibilities: Providing a stable endpoint for accessing the Ray cluster.
  - Security controls: Kubernetes service access control.
- Ingress Controller:
  - Name: Ingress Controller
  - Type: Service
  - Description: An optional Kubernetes ingress controller for external access.
  - Responsibilities: Routing external traffic to the Ray head node service.
  - Security controls: TLS termination, authentication, authorization (depending on the ingress controller).
- Persistent Volume (Optional):
  - Name: Persistent Volume (Optional)
  - Type: Storage
  - Description: Persistent storage for Ray objects or data.
  - Responsibilities: Providing durable storage for Ray data.
  - Security controls: Encryption at rest, access control (depending on the storage provider).

BUILD

Ray's build process involves multiple steps, from compiling native code to packaging Python wheels. Security is a concern throughout this process.

graph LR
    Developer["Developer"] --> GitHub["GitHub Repository"]
    GitHub --> GitHubActions["GitHub Actions (CI)"]
    GitHubActions -- "Builds and Tests" --> Artifacts["Build Artifacts (Wheels, Containers)"]
    Artifacts --> Release["Release (PyPI, Docker Hub)"]

    subgraph GitHub Actions
        Linters["Linters (e.g., Flake8, Pylint)"]
        SAST["SAST (e.g., Bandit)"]
        Tests["Unit & Integration Tests"]
        Build["Build (CMake, setup.py)"]
    end

    Developer -- "Writes code" --> GitHub
    GitHub -- "Triggers CI" --> GitHubActions
    Linters -- "Checks code style" --> Build
    SAST -- "Scans for vulnerabilities" --> Build
    Tests -- "Runs tests" --> Build
    Build -- "Creates artifacts" --> Artifacts

Loading

Description:
- Developers write code and push changes to the GitHub repository.
- GitHub Actions, the CI/CD system, is triggered by pushes and pull requests.
- The CI pipeline performs several steps:
  - Linters: Code style and quality checks (e.g., Flake8, Pylint) are run to identify potential issues.
  - SAST: Static Application Security Testing (e.g., Bandit) is used to scan the codebase for potential vulnerabilities.
  - Tests: Unit and integration tests are executed to ensure code correctness.
  - Build: The build process compiles native code (using CMake) and packages Python wheels (using setup.py).
- Build artifacts (wheels, container images) are created and stored.
- Releases are published to PyPI (for Python packages) and Docker Hub (for container images).
Security Controls:
- Code Review: All code changes undergo mandatory code review before being merged.
- Automated Testing: Extensive unit and integration tests are run automatically in the CI pipeline.
- Static Analysis: Linters and SAST tools are used to identify potential code quality and security issues.
- Dependency Scanning: Dependencies are managed using package managers (pip, conda), allowing for vulnerability scanning.
- Signed Commits: Developers are encouraged to sign their commits using GPG keys.
- GitHub Actions Security: GitHub Actions provides a secure environment for running CI/CD pipelines.

RISK ASSESSMENT

Critical Business Processes:
- Execution of AI/ML workloads: The primary function of Ray is to run distributed computations for AI and ML tasks. Disruption of this process would directly impact users' ability to train models, perform inference, and run other data-intensive applications.
- Data processing and transformation: Ray is often used to process and transform large datasets. Compromise or corruption of this data could have significant consequences, depending on the sensitivity of the data.
- Model deployment and serving: Ray Serve is used to deploy and serve machine learning models. Attacks on the serving infrastructure could lead to incorrect predictions, denial of service, or model theft.
Data We Are Trying to Protect and Sensitivity:
- User Data: This can range from non-sensitive data used for testing to highly sensitive data used in production applications (e.g., financial data, medical records, personal information). Sensitivity: Variable, potentially HIGH.
- Model Parameters: The trained parameters of machine learning models represent valuable intellectual property and can be highly sensitive. Sensitivity: HIGH.
- Source Code: The source code of user applications and custom Ray tasks may contain proprietary algorithms or sensitive information. Sensitivity: Variable, potentially HIGH.
- Cluster Metadata: Information about the Ray cluster, including node addresses, resource usage, and task status. Sensitivity: MEDIUM.
- Authentication Credentials: Usernames, passwords, API keys, and TLS certificates used to access the Ray cluster. Sensitivity: HIGH.

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

Questions:
- What specific compliance requirements (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA, PCI DSS) apply to Ray deployments in different use cases?
- What are the specific threat models and attack vectors that are most relevant to Ray users in different industries?
- What level of security assurance (e.g., penetration testing, formal verification) is required for different Ray deployments?
- What are the performance implications of different security controls, and how can we optimize the trade-off between security and performance?
- How can we improve the usability of Ray's security features to make it easier for users to deploy secure clusters?
- What mechanisms are in place for incident response and vulnerability disclosure?
- Are there any plans to integrate with hardware security modules (HSMs) or trusted platform modules (TPMs)?
Assumptions:
- BUSINESS POSTURE: We assume that Ray users prioritize scalability, performance, and ease of use, but also recognize the importance of security, especially for production deployments.
- SECURITY POSTURE: We assume that Ray's existing security controls provide a reasonable baseline level of security, but that further enhancements are needed to address specific threats and compliance requirements. We assume users will follow security best practices.
- DESIGN: We assume that the Kubernetes deployment model using KubeRay is the most relevant for this threat modeling exercise, as it represents a common and recommended approach for production deployments. We assume that users will have a basic understanding of Kubernetes concepts and security principles.

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

sec-design.md

sec-design.md

BUSINESS POSTURE

SECURITY POSTURE

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

C4 CONTAINER

DEPLOYMENT

BUILD

RISK ASSESSMENT

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

Files

sec-design.md

Latest commit

History

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

BUSINESS POSTURE

SECURITY POSTURE

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

C4 CONTAINER

DEPLOYMENT

BUILD

RISK ASSESSMENT

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS