Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
201 lines (143 loc) · 17.6 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

201 lines (143 loc) · 17.6 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for ankane/chartkick

Objective: Compromise Application via Chartkick Vulnerabilities

Attack Tree Visualization

Root: Compromise Application via Chartkick Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]**
├───[AND] Client-Side Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   └───[OR] Exploit Charting Library Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│       └───[AND] Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Charting Library **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           ├───[AND] Inject Malicious Data into Chart Data **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           │   └───[AND] Application fails to sanitize user-provided data **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           └───[AND] Chartkick passes unsanitized data to vulnerable charting library (Chart.js, Highcharts, Google Charts) **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│           └───[AND] Charting library processes data and renders malicious script **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│           └───[Impact] Execute arbitrary JavaScript in user's browser (Session Hijacking, Defacement, Data Theft) **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
├───[AND] Dependency Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   └───[OR] Outdated Chartkick Dependencies **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│       └───[AND] Chartkick relies on outdated versions of charting libraries (Chart.js, Highcharts, Google Charts) **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│       └───[AND] Known vulnerabilities exist in these outdated versions **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│       └───[AND] Exploit known vulnerabilities in outdated charting libraries **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
└───[AND] Indirect Vulnerabilities via Chartkick Usage
    └───[OR] Information Disclosure via Chart Data **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
        └───[AND] Sensitive data included in chart datasets **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
        └───[AND] Application unintentionally exposes sensitive information in data used for charts **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
        └───[AND] Chartkick renders charts with this sensitive data client-side **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
        └───[AND] Attacker views page with chart and extracts sensitive information **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**

Attack Tree Path: Root: Compromise Application via Chartkick Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Description: This is the ultimate goal of the attacker and the starting point for all attack paths. Success here means the attacker has achieved some level of compromise within the application utilizing Chartkick.

Attack Tree Path: Client-Side Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Description: This category represents vulnerabilities that are exploited on the client-side, within the user's browser, primarily related to how Chartkick and its charting libraries handle data and rendering.
  • Significance: Client-side vulnerabilities, especially XSS, are common and can have a direct impact on users, leading to data theft, session hijacking, and defacement.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Charting Library Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Description: This focuses on exploiting vulnerabilities within the underlying JavaScript charting libraries (Chart.js, Highcharts, Google Charts) that Chartkick wraps.
  • Significance: Chartkick's security heavily relies on the security of these libraries. Vulnerabilities in these libraries directly translate to potential vulnerabilities in applications using Chartkick.

Attack Tree Path: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Charting Library [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Attacker injects malicious data into chart data inputs (labels, data points, tooltips, etc.). If the application fails to sanitize this data, and Chartkick passes it to a vulnerable charting library, the library may render this data as executable JavaScript.
    • Impact: Execution of arbitrary JavaScript in the user's browser. This can lead to:
      • Session Hijacking: Stealing user session cookies to impersonate the user.
      • Defacement: Modifying the visual appearance of the webpage.
      • Data Theft: Stealing sensitive information displayed on the page or performing actions on behalf of the user.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Input Sanitization: Strictly sanitize all user-provided data before using it in Chartkick charts. Use appropriate encoding and escaping techniques.
      • Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strong CSP to limit the impact of XSS by controlling script sources and preventing inline script execution.
      • Regularly Update Charting Libraries: Keep the underlying charting libraries updated to patch known XSS vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: Application fails to sanitize user-provided data [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: The application directly uses user-provided data (e.g., from URL parameters, form inputs, database queries without proper encoding) in the chart configuration or data without sanitization.
    • Impact: This is the root cause that enables XSS vulnerabilities in the charting library. Without sanitization, malicious data can be injected and processed by Chartkick and the charting library.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Input Validation and Sanitization: Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all user-provided data used in chart generation.
      • Secure Coding Practices: Train developers on secure coding practices, emphasizing the importance of input sanitization to prevent XSS.

Attack Tree Path: Chartkick passes unsanitized data to vulnerable charting library [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Chartkick, acting as a wrapper, passes the unsanitized data received from the application directly to the underlying charting library without performing its own sanitization.
    • Impact: Chartkick becomes a conduit for passing malicious data to the vulnerable charting library, enabling the exploitation of vulnerabilities within the library.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Code Review (Chartkick Usage): Review how Chartkick is used in the application to ensure no unsanitized data is passed to it.
      • Ideally, Chartkick should also perform some level of output encoding (though input sanitization at the application level is paramount).

Attack Tree Path: Charting library processes data and renders malicious script [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: A vulnerability exists within the charting library that allows it to process specially crafted data in a way that results in the rendering of malicious JavaScript code within the chart output.
    • Impact: Execution of arbitrary JavaScript in the user's browser (XSS).
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Regularly Update Charting Libraries: Staying updated is crucial to patch known vulnerabilities in the charting libraries.
      • Security Monitoring (Charting Library Advisories): Monitor security advisories and vulnerability databases for the specific charting libraries used (Chart.js, Highcharts, Google Charts).

Attack Tree Path: Execute arbitrary JavaScript in user's browser (Session Hijacking, Defacement, Data Theft) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: This is the successful exploitation of the XSS vulnerability. The attacker's injected JavaScript code is now running in the user's browser context.
    • Impact: Significant compromise of the user's session and potential data breach.
      • Session Hijacking: Full control of the user's account.
      • Defacement: Damage to the application's reputation and user trust.
      • Data Theft: Loss of sensitive user data or application data.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • All previous mitigation steps for XSS are critical to prevent reaching this stage.
      • Incident Response Plan: Have an incident response plan in place to handle XSS attacks and their potential consequences.

Attack Tree Path: Dependency Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Description: This category focuses on vulnerabilities arising from outdated or vulnerable dependencies of Chartkick, specifically the underlying charting libraries.
  • Significance: Dependency vulnerabilities are a common attack vector. Outdated libraries often contain known vulnerabilities that are publicly disclosed and easily exploitable.

Attack Tree Path: Outdated Chartkick Dependencies [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: The application uses outdated versions of Chartkick's dependencies (charting libraries). These outdated versions may contain known security vulnerabilities.
    • Impact: Exposure to known vulnerabilities in the charting libraries, potentially leading to XSS, DoS, or other issues.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Dependency Management: Implement a robust dependency management process.
      • Regularly Update Dependencies: Regularly update Chartkick and its charting library dependencies to the latest versions.
      • Dependency Scanning Tools: Use automated dependency scanning tools to identify outdated and vulnerable dependencies.

Attack Tree Path: Chartkick relies on outdated versions of charting libraries (Chart.js, Highcharts, Google Charts) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: This is the underlying condition that enables dependency vulnerabilities. The application's dependency management practices fail to keep the charting libraries up-to-date.
    • Impact: Creates the vulnerability surface for exploitation.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Automated Dependency Updates: Consider automating dependency updates as part of the development and deployment pipeline.
      • Dependency Monitoring: Continuously monitor dependencies for new versions and security updates.

Attack Tree Path: Known vulnerabilities exist in these outdated versions [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Publicly disclosed vulnerabilities are present in the outdated versions of the charting libraries being used.
    • Impact: Makes exploitation easier as vulnerability details and potentially even exploits are publicly available.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Vulnerability Databases: Regularly check vulnerability databases (e.g., CVE databases, security advisories) for known vulnerabilities in the charting libraries used.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit known vulnerabilities in outdated charting libraries [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Attackers exploit the publicly known vulnerabilities in the outdated charting libraries. Exploits are often readily available or easy to develop for known vulnerabilities.
    • Impact: Successful exploitation can lead to XSS, DoS, or other impacts depending on the specific vulnerability.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Patch Management: Prioritize patching outdated dependencies with known vulnerabilities.
      • Security Testing (Vulnerability Scanning): Include vulnerability scanning as part of the security testing process to identify outdated and vulnerable dependencies.

Attack Tree Path: Information Disclosure via Chart Data [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Sensitive data is unintentionally included in the datasets used to generate charts. Chartkick renders these charts client-side, making the data visible in the browser's source code or developer tools.
    • Impact: Exposure of sensitive information to unauthorized users who can view the webpage. This can lead to privacy violations, identity theft, or other forms of harm depending on the nature of the disclosed data.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Data Minimization: Carefully review the data used for charts and avoid including sensitive or unnecessary information.
      • Data Sanitization (for Display): If sensitive data must be displayed, consider anonymization, aggregation, or masking techniques.
      • Access Control: Implement appropriate access controls to restrict access to pages containing charts with potentially sensitive data to authorized users only.
      • Code Review (Data Handling): Conduct code reviews to ensure that sensitive data is not inadvertently included in chart datasets.

Attack Tree Path: Sensitive data included in chart datasets [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Developers or the application logic unintentionally or carelessly include sensitive information in the data structures that are passed to Chartkick for rendering charts.
    • Impact: Creates the condition for potential information disclosure.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Data Classification: Classify data based on sensitivity levels to ensure appropriate handling and prevent accidental exposure.
      • Principle of Least Privilege (Data Access): Only use the minimum necessary data required for chart generation.

Attack Tree Path: Application unintentionally exposes sensitive information in data used for charts [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: The application's design or implementation flaws lead to the inclusion of sensitive data in chart datasets. This could be due to incorrect data filtering, logging sensitive information, or using sensitive data directly without proper consideration for client-side exposure.
    • Impact: Direct exposure of sensitive data in the chart rendering process.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Security Design Review: Conduct security design reviews to identify potential information disclosure risks in the application's data handling and chart generation processes.
      • Data Flow Analysis: Analyze data flow within the application to track how sensitive data is used and ensure it's not inadvertently exposed in charts.

Attack Tree Path: Chartkick renders charts with this sensitive data client-side [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: Chartkick, by design, renders charts client-side, meaning the data used to create the charts is sent to the user's browser and processed there. This inherently makes the data visible in the client-side context.
    • Impact: Makes the sensitive data readily accessible to anyone who can view the webpage's source code or use browser developer tools.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Understand Client-Side Rendering Implications: Developers must be fully aware of the security implications of client-side rendering and avoid exposing sensitive data in client-side code.
      • Consider Server-Side Rendering (If Feasible and Necessary): In cases where extreme data sensitivity is a concern, explore server-side rendering options (though Chartkick is primarily client-side focused, server-side rendering might be possible with underlying libraries or alternative solutions).

Attack Tree Path: Attacker views page with chart and extracts sensitive information [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:
    • Mechanism: An attacker simply accesses the webpage containing the chart with sensitive data and uses standard browser features (view source, developer tools) to extract the exposed data.
    • Impact: Data breach and information disclosure.
    • Actionable Insights:
      • Prevent Sensitive Data Exposure (Primary Mitigation): The most effective mitigation is to prevent sensitive data from being included in chart datasets in the first place (as highlighted in previous steps).
      • Access Control (Secondary Mitigation): Implement access controls to limit who can view pages containing potentially sensitive charts.