Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
179 lines (132 loc) · 16.3 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

179 lines (132 loc) · 16.3 KB

Deep Security Analysis of Chartkick

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective:

The objective of this deep security analysis is to thoroughly examine the Chartkick library (https://github.com/ankane/chartkick) and its integration within a Ruby on Rails application, identifying potential security vulnerabilities and providing actionable mitigation strategies. The analysis focuses on:

  • Data Flow: How data moves through the system, from user input (if any) to chart rendering.
  • Input Validation: Where and how input validation and sanitization should occur.
  • Dependency Risks: Security implications of Chartkick's reliance on external JavaScript charting libraries (Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts).
  • Integration with Rails: How Chartkick interacts with Rails' security features and potential gaps.
  • Deployment and Build: Security considerations for the deployment and build processes.

Scope:

This analysis covers:

  • The Chartkick Ruby gem itself.
  • The interaction between Chartkick and the chosen JavaScript charting library (Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts).
  • The integration of Chartkick within a Ruby on Rails application.
  • The typical deployment and build processes for a Rails application using Chartkick.

This analysis does not cover:

  • In-depth security reviews of the underlying JavaScript charting libraries (Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts). We will rely on their respective security documentation and assume they are regularly updated.
  • General security best practices for Ruby on Rails applications that are not directly related to Chartkick.
  • Security of the underlying operating system, network infrastructure, or database server, except as it directly relates to the deployment of the Chartkick-enabled application.

Methodology:

  1. Code Review: Examine the Chartkick source code on GitHub to understand its internal workings and identify potential security-relevant areas.
  2. Documentation Review: Analyze the Chartkick documentation, as well as the documentation for the supported charting libraries (Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts), to understand their security models and recommendations.
  3. Architecture Inference: Based on the code, documentation, and C4 diagrams provided, infer the overall architecture, components, and data flow of a Rails application using Chartkick.
  4. Threat Modeling: Identify potential threats based on the identified architecture and data flow, focusing on common web application vulnerabilities (e.g., XSS, injection, DoS).
  5. Mitigation Recommendations: Propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies to address the identified threats, tailored to the Chartkick context.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

Based on the Security Design Review and inferred architecture, here's a breakdown of the security implications of key components:

  • Chartkick Gem (Ruby):

    • Role: Acts as a bridge between the Rails application and the JavaScript charting library. It primarily generates JavaScript code based on Ruby method calls and data provided by the Rails application.
    • Security Implications:
      • Low Direct Risk: Chartkick itself doesn't directly handle user input or perform rendering. Its primary function is code generation.
      • Indirect Risk (XSS): The most significant risk is that Chartkick could be used to generate malicious JavaScript if the data passed to it from the Rails application is not properly sanitized. This could lead to Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities. If user-supplied data is used to construct chart labels, titles, or data values, and that data contains JavaScript code, Chartkick will happily generate the corresponding (malicious) JavaScript.
      • Dependency Management: Relies on the bundler to manage dependencies. Vulnerabilities in these dependencies could be exploited.

  • Charting Library (JS: Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts):

    • Role: Performs the actual rendering of the chart in the user's browser, based on the JavaScript code generated by Chartkick.
    • Security Implications:
      • XSS (Primary Concern): Each charting library has its own handling of user-provided data and its own potential for XSS vulnerabilities. While these libraries generally aim to be secure, vulnerabilities can and do exist. Regular updates are crucial.
      • Data Handling: The charting library receives data directly from the generated JavaScript. If this data is sensitive, it's exposed in the client-side code.
      • DoS: Complex or excessively large charts could potentially lead to denial-of-service (DoS) conditions in the user's browser, especially on less powerful devices. This is more of a performance issue but can have security implications.
      • Library-Specific Vulnerabilities: Each library has its own potential vulnerabilities. For example, older versions of Chart.js were known to have XSS vulnerabilities related to tooltips and labels.

  • Rails Application:

    • Role: Provides the data to Chartkick, handles user authentication and authorization, and manages the overall application logic. This is the most critical component for Chartkick security.
    • Security Implications:
      • Input Validation (Crucial): The Rails application must thoroughly validate and sanitize all data passed to Chartkick, especially if that data originates from user input. This is the primary defense against XSS.
      • Authentication and Authorization: The Rails application is responsible for ensuring that only authorized users can access data displayed in charts. Chartkick has no built-in authentication or authorization mechanisms.
      • Data Protection: If sensitive data is displayed in charts, the Rails application must implement appropriate security measures (e.g., encryption at rest and in transit) to protect that data.
      • CSRF Protection: Rails' built-in CSRF protection helps prevent attackers from forging requests that could modify data or application state, indirectly protecting the data displayed in charts.

  • Database:

    • Role: Stores the data that may be used to generate charts.
    • Security Implications:
      • Data Security: The database must be properly secured to prevent unauthorized access to the data. This includes access controls, encryption, and regular security audits.
      • SQL Injection: While not directly related to Chartkick, SQL injection vulnerabilities in the Rails application could allow attackers to exfiltrate data that might be displayed in charts.

  • User (Web Browser):

    • Role: Views and interacts with the charts.
    • Security Implications:
      • Relies on browser security features (e.g., same-origin policy, HTTPS) to protect against attacks.
      • Vulnerable to XSS attacks if the application is not properly secured.

3. Architecture, Components, and Data Flow (Inferred)

The C4 diagrams provided a good starting point. Here's a refined understanding:

  1. User Request: A user makes a request to the Rails application (e.g., to view a page containing a chart).
  2. Rails Controller: The Rails controller handles the request, retrieves data from the database (potentially based on user input or parameters), and prepares the data for Chartkick.
  3. Chartkick Invocation: The controller calls Chartkick methods (e.g., line_chart, pie_chart) to generate the JavaScript code for the chart, passing in the prepared data.
  4. JavaScript Generation: Chartkick generates the JavaScript code, including the data and options for the chosen charting library (e.g., Chart.js).
  5. View Rendering: The Rails view renders the HTML, including the generated JavaScript code (typically within a <script> tag or as a data attribute).
  6. Browser Execution: The user's browser receives the HTML and executes the JavaScript code.
  7. Chart Rendering: The charting library (e.g., Chart.js) parses the data and options and renders the chart in the browser.
  8. User Interaction: The user interacts with the chart (e.g., hovering over data points, clicking on elements). These interactions are handled by the charting library.

Key Data Flow Points:

  • User Input -> Rails Controller: This is a critical point for input validation and sanitization.
  • Rails Controller -> Chartkick: Data passed here must be sanitized to prevent XSS.
  • Chartkick -> Generated JavaScript: This is where the potential for injecting malicious code exists if the input is not sanitized.
  • Generated JavaScript -> Charting Library: The charting library receives the data and is responsible for rendering it securely.
  • Charting Library -> User's Browser: The rendered chart is displayed to the user.

4. Specific Security Considerations for Chartkick

Given the architecture and data flow, here are specific security considerations:

  • Overwhelming Reliance on Rails Application Security: Chartkick's security is almost entirely dependent on the security practices of the Rails application using it. This is a significant point to emphasize.
  • XSS is the Primary Threat: The most likely and impactful vulnerability is Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) due to unsanitized data being passed to Chartkick.
  • Dependency Vulnerabilities: Vulnerabilities in Chartkick's dependencies (including the charting libraries) are a significant concern. Regular updates are essential.
  • Data Exposure in Client-Side Code: All data used to generate the chart is exposed in the client-side JavaScript code. This is unavoidable, but it means sensitive data should be handled with extreme care.
  • No Built-in Input Validation: Chartkick does not perform any input validation or sanitization. This is entirely the responsibility of the Rails application.
  • No Authentication or Authorization: Chartkick does not handle authentication or authorization. These must be implemented in the Rails application.
  • Potential for DoS (via Charting Library): While less likely, excessively complex charts could potentially lead to browser performance issues or even denial of service.

5. Actionable Mitigation Strategies (Tailored to Chartkick)

These are specific, actionable recommendations to mitigate the identified threats:

  1. Robust Input Validation and Sanitization (Rails Application - Critical):

    • Whitelist Approach: Whenever possible, use a whitelist approach to input validation. Define exactly what characters and data types are allowed, and reject anything that doesn't match.
    • Rails' sanitize Helper: Use Rails' built-in sanitize helper to remove or escape potentially dangerous HTML tags and attributes from user input before passing it to Chartkick. Be very careful with the sanitize helper's options; the default settings may not be sufficient. Consider using a more restrictive configuration. 
      # In your controller or helper
sanitized_data = sanitize(user_input, tags: %w[b i strong em], attributes: %w[]) # Very restrictive!
@chart_data = { name: 'Series 1', data: [['Label 1', sanitized_data], ['Label 2', 10]] }
    • Context-Specific Escaping: Understand the context in which the data will be used within the chart. Different parts of a chart (labels, titles, data values) may require different escaping strategies. The charting library's documentation may provide guidance on this.
    • Avoid html_safe: Do not mark user-provided data as html_safe before passing it to Chartkick. This bypasses Rails' built-in escaping and creates a high risk of XSS.
    • Custom Validation: For complex data structures, implement custom validation logic to ensure that all parts of the data are safe.
    • Example (Chart.js): If using Chart.js, be particularly aware of potential XSS vulnerabilities in tooltips and labels. Ensure that any user-provided data used in these elements is properly escaped.

  2. Regular Dependency Updates (Rails Application & Chartkick):

    • bundle update: Regularly run bundle update chartkick and bundle update to update Chartkick and all its dependencies, including the JavaScript charting libraries.
    • Automated Dependency Scanning: Use tools like bundler-audit (as mentioned in the build process) to automatically scan for known vulnerabilities in your gem dependencies. Integrate this into your CI/CD pipeline.
    • Monitor Charting Library Security Advisories: Stay informed about security advisories and updates for the specific charting library you are using (Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts). Subscribe to their mailing lists or follow their security blogs.

  3. Content Security Policy (CSP) (Rails Application):

    • Implement a Strict CSP: Implement a Content Security Policy (CSP) in your Rails application to mitigate the impact of XSS attacks. A well-configured CSP can prevent the browser from executing injected malicious scripts, even if an XSS vulnerability exists.
    • script-src Directive: Pay close attention to the script-src directive in your CSP. You'll likely need to allow scripts from the CDN where your charting library is hosted (e.g., https://cdn.jsdelivr.net). Avoid using 'unsafe-inline' if at all possible. Consider using nonces or hashes for inline scripts. 
      # config/initializers/content_security_policy.rb
Rails.application.config.content_security_policy do |policy|
  policy.default_src :self, :https
  policy.script_src  :self, :https, 'https://cdn.jsdelivr.net' # Allow Chart.js from CDN
  # ... other directives ...
end

  4. Data Minimization (Rails Application):

    • Only Pass Necessary Data: Only pass the data that is absolutely necessary for the chart to Chartkick. Avoid including any sensitive data that is not directly used in the chart.
    • Consider Server-Side Rendering (if feasible): For highly sensitive data, explore options for server-side chart rendering (e.g., using a library that generates images on the server). This would avoid exposing the data in the client-side code. This is a significant architectural change and may not be practical in all cases.

  5. Secure Deployment and Build (Rails Application):

    • Follow Security Best Practices: Follow all security best practices for deploying and building Rails applications, as outlined in the provided C4 diagrams and build process description. This includes:
      • Using a minimal base image for Docker containers.
      • Regularly updating the base image and all dependencies.
      • Running security checks (SAST, dependency scanning) in the CI/CD pipeline.
      • Securely managing secrets and credentials.
      • Using a secure container registry.
      • Implementing network policies and RBAC in Kubernetes.
      • Using a load balancer with SSL/TLS termination and DDoS protection.

  6. Monitoring and Logging (Rails Application):

    • Monitor for Suspicious Activity: Monitor your application logs for any signs of suspicious activity, such as unusual input patterns or errors related to chart rendering.
    • Log Chart Data (with Caution): Consider logging the data passed to Chartkick (after sanitization) for debugging and auditing purposes. Be extremely careful not to log any sensitive data.

  7. Choose Charting Library Wisely:

    • Research the security track record of each supported library (Chart.js, Google Charts, Highcharts).
    • Prefer libraries with active security communities and prompt vulnerability patching.

  8. Sanitize Chart Options:

    • If your application allows users to customize chart options (e.g., colors, titles, axis labels), sanitize these options as well to prevent XSS. Even seemingly harmless options could be exploited if not handled correctly.

By implementing these mitigation strategies, you can significantly reduce the security risks associated with using Chartkick in your Rails application. The most crucial step is to thoroughly validate and sanitize all data passed to Chartkick, especially if it originates from user input. Remember that Chartkick's security is heavily reliant on the security of the surrounding Rails application.