Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
110 lines (85 loc) · 6.69 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

110 lines (85 loc) · 6.69 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for bkeepers/dotenv

Mitigation Strategy: Strict .gitignore (and Similar) Enforcement

Description:

  1. Create .gitignore: Before creating any .env files, create a .gitignore file in the root of your project repository.
  2. Add .env Entries: Add the following lines to your .gitignore file: 
    .env
.env.*
    This prevents .env and any files starting with .env. (e.g., .env.local, .env.test) from being tracked by Git. This is directly related to dotenv because it's preventing the files used by dotenv from being exposed.
  3. Global .gitignore (Optional but Recommended): Configure a global .gitignore file. Add .env and .env.* to it.
  4. Pre-Commit Hooks: Install pre-commit. Create a .pre-commit-config.yaml file. Add configurations to forbid .env files (see example in previous responses). Run pre-commit install. This directly prevents committing files that dotenv uses.
  5. Regular Audits: Periodically inspect the repository's history to ensure no .env files have been accidentally committed. Use Git commands like git log --all -- .env.
  6. Immediate Remediation: If a .env file is found, immediately rotate all secrets.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Accidental Secret Exposure (Severity: Critical): Prevents the .env files used by dotenv from being exposed.
  • Unauthorized Access (Severity: Critical): Reduces unauthorized access by preventing dotenv's credential files from leaking.
  • Compliance Violations (Severity: High): Helps meet compliance by protecting the data dotenv manages.

Impact:

  • Accidental Secret Exposure: Risk reduced to near zero.
  • Unauthorized Access: Significantly reduces the attack surface.
  • Compliance Violations: Helps achieve and maintain compliance.

Currently Implemented:

  • .gitignore file exists and includes .env and .env.*.
  • Pre-commit hooks are configured.

Missing Implementation:

  • Global .gitignore is not yet configured for all developers.
  • Regular audit process is not yet formalized.

Mitigation Strategy: Environment Variable Validation (with dotenv)

Description:

  1. Choose a Validation Library: Select a schema validation library (e.g., joi, pydantic, cerberus).
  2. Define a Schema: Create a schema defining the expected structure, types, and constraints for each environment variable that dotenv loads.
  3. Validate After dotenv Load: After calling dotenv.config(), validate the process.env (or equivalent) object against your schema. This is crucial: you're validating the data after dotenv has populated it.
  4. Fail Fast: If validation fails, terminate immediately with a clear error.
  5. Log Errors: Log validation errors.
  6. Test Validation: Write unit tests.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Application Misconfiguration (Severity: Medium to High): Prevents the application from running with incorrect values loaded by dotenv.
  • Injection Attacks (Severity: Medium to High): Adds a layer of defense against injection if variables loaded by dotenv are used unsafely.
  • Data Corruption (Severity: Medium): Prevents invalid data loaded by dotenv from corrupting application state.

Impact:

  • Application Misconfiguration: Significantly reduces misconfiguration.
  • Injection Attacks: Provides an additional layer of defense.
  • Data Corruption: Reduces the risk.

Currently Implemented:

  • Basic validation schema using joi.
  • Checks for presence of required variables.

Missing Implementation:

  • Schema is not comprehensive (needs format validation).
  • Unit tests are incomplete.
  • Error logging is not implemented.

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege (Within the .env File)

Description:

  1. Inventory: List all environment variables currently in the .env file used by dotenv.
  2. Justification: Determine if each variable is absolutely necessary. Document the purpose.
  3. Removal: Remove any non-essential variables from the .env file. Consider environment-specific .env files (e.g., .env.development), loaded conditionally by dotenv. Remember to .gitignore all of these.
  4. Review: Regularly review the .env file contents.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Information Disclosure (Severity: Medium): Reduces the amount of sensitive information in the .env file that dotenv uses.
  • Attack Surface Reduction (Severity: Low to Medium): Minimizes the number of secrets managed by dotenv.

Impact:

  • Information Disclosure: Reduces the impact of a .env file leak.
  • Attack Surface Reduction: Contributes to a smaller attack surface.

Currently Implemented:

  • Preliminary review of variables.

Missing Implementation:

  • Formal inventory and justification process is not in place.
  • Environment-specific .env files are not consistently used.

Mitigation Strategy: Limit dotenv scope

Description:

  1. Identify Required Variables: Determine the specific environment variables needed for each part of your application.
  2. Specific Path: Use the path option in dotenv.config() to specify the exact location of the .env file. Example: dotenv.config({ path: './config/.env.development' }); This is directly controlling how dotenv behaves.
  3. Modularize Configuration: (If possible) Structure your application so different modules only load the variables they need, potentially using separate .env files and multiple dotenv.config() calls with different paths.
  4. Avoid Default Behavior: Be aware of dotenv's default search behavior (current and parent directories). Explicit paths prevent accidental loading.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Accidental Loading of Incorrect .env File (Severity: Medium): Reduces the risk of dotenv loading the wrong file.
  • Information Disclosure (Severity: Low): Limits exposure if a vulnerability allows reading environment variables, by controlling which variables dotenv loads.

Impact:

  • Accidental Loading of Incorrect .env File: Significantly reduces this risk.
  • Information Disclosure: Provides a small reduction in impact.

Currently Implemented:

  • None. The application uses the default dotenv.config() without specifying a path.

Missing Implementation:

  • Refactor to use dotenv.config({ path: ... }) with specific paths.
  • Consider modularizing configuration.