Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
87 lines (72 loc) · 8.08 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

87 lines (72 loc) · 8.08 KB

Threat Model Analysis for heartcombo/devise

Threat: Account Enumeration via Timing/Error Analysis

  • Description: An attacker sends multiple requests to the login, registration, or password reset forms, varying the username/email. They analyze subtle differences in response times or error messages (e.g., "Invalid email or password" vs. "Email not found") to determine if an account exists.
  • Impact: The attacker can compile a list of valid usernames/emails, which can be used for targeted attacks like phishing, credential stuffing, or brute-force attempts.
  • Devise Component Affected: Confirmable, Recoverable, Registerable, and the core authentication logic. Specifically, the controller actions and views related to these modules.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Consistent Response Times: Implement a delay to ensure all responses (success or failure) take approximately the same time. This can be tricky to get right.
    • Generic Error Messages: Use generic error messages that don't reveal whether the username/email exists (e.g., "Invalid login credentials").
    • Rate Limiting: Implement rate limiting (e.g., with rack-attack) to slow down enumeration attempts.
    • CAPTCHA: Use CAPTCHAs on sensitive forms to deter automated attacks.
    • config.paranoid = true: While not a complete solution, setting config.paranoid = true in devise.rb can help, but requires careful additional measures.

Threat: Brute-Force Login Attacks

  • Description: An attacker uses automated tools to systematically try a large number of password combinations against the login form.
  • Impact: Account takeover, unauthorized access to user data and application functionality.
  • Devise Component Affected: Core authentication logic (primarily the SessionsController).
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Account Lockout: Use Devise's Lockable module to lock accounts after a configurable number of failed login attempts. Configure appropriate lockout duration and unlock mechanisms.
    • Rate Limiting: Implement rate limiting (e.g., with rack-attack) to limit the number of login attempts from a single IP address within a time window.
    • Strong Password Policies: Enforce strong password requirements (length, complexity, and potentially password history checks).
    • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Implement MFA to add an extra layer of security.

Threat: Credential Stuffing

  • Description: An attacker uses lists of compromised usernames and passwords (obtained from data breaches of other services) to attempt to log in to the application.
  • Impact: Account takeover, unauthorized access to user data and application functionality.
  • Devise Component Affected: Core authentication logic (primarily the SessionsController).
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Account Lockout: Use Devise's Lockable module (as with brute-force attacks).
    • Rate Limiting: Implement rate limiting (as with brute-force attacks).
    • Password Reuse Prevention: Ideally, integrate with a service that checks for compromised passwords (e.g., Have I Been Pwned API), though this has privacy implications. At a minimum, prevent users from reusing their own previous passwords.
    • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Implement MFA.
    • User Education: Educate users about the risks of password reuse and encourage them to use unique, strong passwords.

Threat: Weak Password Reset Token Generation/Handling

  • Description: An attacker exploits weaknesses in the password reset process, such as predictable tokens, insufficient token expiration, or vulnerabilities in the email delivery system, to gain unauthorized access to accounts.
  • Impact: Account takeover.
  • Devise Component Affected: Recoverable module. Specifically, the token generation, storage, and validation logic.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Secure Token Generation: Ensure Devise is using a cryptographically secure random number generator for reset tokens (this should be the default, but verify).
    • Short Token Expiration: Set a short, reasonable expiration time for password reset tokens (e.g., 1 hour).
    • Secure Email Delivery: Use a reputable email provider and secure SMTP settings. Monitor for email spoofing.
    • Token Invalidation: Invalidate all active sessions and password reset tokens after a successful password reset.
    • Additional Verification: Consider requiring additional verification during password reset (e.g., security questions – but be aware of their limitations). Avoid sending the new password in the email.

Threat: Outdated Devise Gem

  • Description: An attacker exploits a known vulnerability in an older version of the Devise gem.
  • Impact: Varies depending on the specific vulnerability, but could range from information disclosure to complete account takeover.
  • Devise Component Affected: Potentially any module or part of Devise.
  • Risk Severity: High (if a known exploit exists)
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Regular Updates: Keep Devise updated to the latest stable version.
    • Dependency Monitoring: Use tools like bundler-audit or Dependabot to monitor for vulnerable dependencies.

Threat: Insecure secret_key_base

  • Description: The Rails secret_key_base (used by Devise for cryptographic operations) is compromised (e.g., stored in version control, exposed in logs, or easily guessable).
  • Impact: An attacker can forge authentication tokens and gain unauthorized access to any account. This is a critical vulnerability.
  • Devise Component Affected: All components that rely on cryptographic operations (which is most of them).
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Secure Storage: Never store secret_key_base in version control.
    • Environment Variables: Use environment variables or a secure secrets management solution (e.g., Rails encrypted credentials, HashiCorp Vault) to store the secret key.
    • Regular Rotation: Rotate the secret_key_base periodically.

Threat: Weak or Bypassed Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) when integrated directly with Devise logic

  • Description: If MFA is implemented and the implementation directly hooks into or modifies Devise's core authentication flow, an attacker finds a way to bypass it due to implementation flaws within that integration, weak token generation, or vulnerabilities in the MFA provider as used within the Devise context. This is distinct from a general MFA bypass; it's about the Devise-specific integration.
  • Impact: Account takeover, even with MFA enabled.
  • Devise Component Affected: The custom code integrating Devise with the MFA gem, potentially overriding Devise's SessionsController or other core methods.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Reputable MFA Gem: Use a well-vetted and actively maintained MFA gem.
    • Secure Integration: Follow the MFA gem's documentation precisely. Avoid unnecessary modifications to Devise's core logic. If overriding Devise methods, ensure the overrides are secure and maintain Devise's security guarantees.
    • Thorough Testing: Test the integrated MFA and Devise flow extensively, including specific bypass attempts targeting the integration points.
    • Strong Token Generation: Use strong, cryptographically secure random number generators for MFA tokens.
    • Hardware Tokens: Consider using hardware-based MFA tokens (e.g., YubiKeys) for higher security.