Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
192 lines (145 loc) · 24.4 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

192 lines (145 loc) · 24.4 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for opf/openproject

Objective: To gain unauthorized access to sensitive project data, manipulate project workflows, or disrupt the application's availability by exploiting vulnerabilities within the OpenProject platform.

Attack Tree Visualization

Attack Goal: Compromise Application via OpenProject

├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** 1. Exploit Authentication and Authorization Flaws in OpenProject
│   ├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** 1.2. Session Hijacking/Fixation
│   │   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 1.2.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) to Steal Session Cookies (OpenProject Specific)
│   │   │   └── ... (Details below)
│   │   └── ...
│   └── **[CRITICAL NODE]** 1.3. Privilege Escalation within OpenProject
│       ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 1.3.1. Exploiting Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) Weaknesses
│       │   └── ... (Details below)
│       ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 1.3.2. API Abuse for Privilege Escalation (OpenProject API Specific)
│       │   └── ... (Details below)
│       └── ...
│   └── ...
├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** 2. Exploit Input Validation Vulnerabilities in OpenProject Modules
│   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 2.1. SQL Injection in OpenProject Database Queries
│   │   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 2.1.1. Exploiting Vulnerable Search Functionality (OpenProject Search)
│   │   │   └── ... (Details below)
│   │   └── ...
│   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 2.2. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) in OpenProject Features
│   │       ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 2.2.1. Stored XSS in Task Descriptions, Comments, Wiki Pages, Forum Posts
│   │       │   └── ... (Details below)
│   │       └── ...
│   └── ...
├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** 3. Exploit Vulnerable Dependencies of OpenProject
│   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 3.1. Known Vulnerabilities in Ruby on Rails Framework (If Applicable)
│   │   └── ... (Details below)
│   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 3.2. Vulnerabilities in Gems (Ruby Libraries) Used by OpenProject
│   │   └── ... (Details below)
│   └── ...
├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** 5. Exploit File Upload and Handling Vulnerabilities in OpenProject
│   ├── **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** 5.1. Unrestricted File Upload leading to Remote Code Execution
│   │   └── ... (Details below)
│   └── ...
└── ...

Attack Tree Path: 1. Exploit Authentication and Authorization Flaws in OpenProject [CRITICAL NODE]

  • This category represents fundamental weaknesses in how OpenProject verifies user identity and manages access permissions. Successful exploitation can grant attackers unauthorized access to the application and its data.

    • 1.2. Session Hijacking/Fixation [CRITICAL NODE]

      • Focuses on vulnerabilities related to session management, allowing attackers to take over legitimate user sessions.
        • 1.2.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) to Steal Session Cookies (OpenProject Specific) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • Attack Vector: An attacker injects malicious JavaScript code into OpenProject features that handle user-generated content (e.g., task descriptions, wiki pages, forum posts, custom fields). When another user views this content, the JavaScript executes in their browser.
          • Exploitation in OpenProject: If OpenProject does not properly sanitize user inputs in these areas, stored XSS vulnerabilities can arise. The malicious script can then steal the user's session cookie and send it to the attacker.
          • Impact: Account takeover. The attacker can impersonate the victim user, gaining access to their projects, data, and potentially administrative privileges if the victim is an administrator.

    • 1.3. Privilege Escalation within OpenProject [CRITICAL NODE]

      • Targets flaws in OpenProject's role-based access control (RBAC) or API authorization, allowing attackers to gain higher privileges than they are supposed to have.

        • 1.3.1. Exploiting Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) Weaknesses [HIGH-RISK PATH]

          • Attack Vector: Attackers identify flaws in OpenProject's RBAC implementation. This could involve bypassing permission checks, exploiting misconfigurations in roles, or finding logic errors in how permissions are enforced.
          • Exploitation in OpenProject: By manipulating requests or exploiting vulnerabilities in the UI or API, an attacker might be able to elevate their privileges from a regular user to a project administrator or even a system administrator within OpenProject.
          • Impact: Unauthorized access to sensitive project data, ability to modify project settings, manipulate workflows, and potentially gain full control over the OpenProject instance.

        • 1.3.2. API Abuse for Privilege Escalation (OpenProject API Specific) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

          • Attack Vector: If the application uses OpenProject's API, attackers target API endpoints that might have insufficient authorization checks. They attempt to access API endpoints or manipulate API requests in a way that allows them to perform actions beyond their authorized privileges.
          • Exploitation in OpenProject: By crafting specific API requests, an attacker might be able to bypass authorization checks and perform actions like creating projects, modifying user roles, or accessing sensitive data through the API, even if they lack the necessary permissions in the UI.
          • Impact: Similar to RBAC exploitation, leading to unauthorized access, data manipulation, and potential full control depending on the API vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit Input Validation Vulnerabilities in OpenProject Modules [CRITICAL NODE]

  • This category focuses on vulnerabilities arising from OpenProject's failure to properly validate user inputs, leading to injection attacks.

    • 2.1. SQL Injection in OpenProject Database Queries [HIGH-RISK PATH]

      • Targets vulnerabilities where user-supplied data is directly incorporated into SQL queries without proper sanitization, allowing attackers to manipulate database operations.
        • 2.1.1. Exploiting Vulnerable Search Functionality (OpenProject Search) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • Attack Vector: Attackers inject malicious SQL code into search queries within OpenProject's search features (e.g., task search, wiki search, user search). If OpenProject's search functionality does not use parameterized queries or secure ORM practices, this injected SQL code can be executed by the database.
          • Exploitation in OpenProject: By crafting specific search terms containing SQL injection payloads, an attacker can bypass intended query logic and execute arbitrary SQL commands on the OpenProject database.
          • Impact: Database compromise. Attackers can read sensitive data from the database, modify data, or even potentially gain control of the database server itself, leading to full application compromise.

    • 2.2. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) in OpenProject Features [HIGH-RISK PATH]

      • Targets vulnerabilities where user-supplied data is displayed to other users without proper encoding, allowing attackers to inject and execute malicious scripts in users' browsers.
        • 2.2.1. Stored XSS in Task Descriptions, Comments, Wiki Pages, Forum Posts [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • Attack Vector: As described in 1.2.1, attackers inject malicious JavaScript code into user-generated content areas. This code is stored in the database and executed every time another user views the affected content.
          • Exploitation in OpenProject: If OpenProject fails to sanitize user inputs in these areas, stored XSS vulnerabilities become persistent. The malicious script can then be used to steal session cookies, redirect users to malicious sites, deface pages, or perform other actions in the context of the victim user's session.
          • Impact: Account takeover (via session cookie theft), defacement, phishing attacks, and potential further exploitation depending on the malicious script's capabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Exploit Vulnerable Dependencies of OpenProject [CRITICAL NODE]

  • This category focuses on vulnerabilities present in the third-party libraries and frameworks that OpenProject relies upon.

    • 3.1. Known Vulnerabilities in Ruby on Rails Framework (If Applicable) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

      • Attack Vector: OpenProject is built on Ruby on Rails. If the OpenProject instance is running on an outdated or vulnerable version of Rails, attackers can exploit known vulnerabilities in the framework itself.
      • Exploitation in OpenProject: Publicly disclosed vulnerabilities in Rails can be exploited to gain unauthorized access, execute arbitrary code, or bypass security controls within the OpenProject application.
      • Impact: Framework-level vulnerabilities can be severe, potentially leading to Remote Code Execution (RCE), complete server compromise, data breaches, and denial of service.

    • 3.2. Vulnerabilities in Gems (Ruby Libraries) Used by OpenProject [HIGH-RISK PATH]

      • Attack Vector: OpenProject uses various Ruby libraries (gems). If any of these gems have known vulnerabilities, attackers can exploit them to compromise OpenProject.
      • Exploitation in OpenProject: Vulnerable gems can introduce various security flaws, including injection vulnerabilities, authentication bypasses, or RCE. Exploiting these vulnerabilities can allow attackers to gain control of the application or server.
      • Impact: Similar to Rails vulnerabilities, gem vulnerabilities can lead to a wide range of impacts, including RCE, data breaches, and denial of service, depending on the specific vulnerability and the affected gem's role in OpenProject.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Exploit File Upload and Handling Vulnerabilities in OpenProject [CRITICAL NODE]

  • This category focuses on vulnerabilities related to how OpenProject handles file uploads, which can be a significant attack vector if not properly secured.

    • 5.1. Unrestricted File Upload leading to Remote Code Execution [HIGH-RISK PATH]
      • Attack Vector: If OpenProject allows users to upload files without proper validation of file types and content, attackers can upload malicious files, such as web shells (e.g., PHP, JSP, ASPX scripts).
      • Exploitation in OpenProject: By uploading a web shell and accessing it through the web server, an attacker can execute arbitrary code on the server hosting OpenProject.
      • Impact: Remote Code Execution (RCE). Full server compromise. The attacker gains complete control over the server, allowing them to access sensitive data, install malware, pivot to other systems, and disrupt application availability.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2. Session Hijacking/Fixation [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Focuses on vulnerabilities related to session management, allowing attackers to take over legitimate user sessions. * 1.2.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) to Steal Session Cookies (OpenProject Specific) [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: An attacker injects malicious JavaScript code into OpenProject features that handle user-generated content (e.g., task descriptions, wiki pages, forum posts, custom fields). When another user views this content, the JavaScript executes in their browser. * Exploitation in OpenProject: If OpenProject does not properly sanitize user inputs in these areas, stored XSS vulnerabilities can arise. The malicious script can then steal the user's session cookie and send it to the attacker. * Impact: Account takeover. The attacker can impersonate the victim user, gaining access to their projects, data, and potentially administrative privileges if the victim is an administrator.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) to Steal Session Cookies (OpenProject Specific) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: An attacker injects malicious JavaScript code into OpenProject features that handle user-generated content (e.g., task descriptions, wiki pages, forum posts, custom fields). When another user views this content, the JavaScript executes in their browser. * Exploitation in OpenProject: If OpenProject does not properly sanitize user inputs in these areas, stored XSS vulnerabilities can arise. The malicious script can then steal the user's session cookie and send it to the attacker. * Impact: Account takeover. The attacker can impersonate the victim user, gaining access to their projects, data, and potentially administrative privileges if the victim is an administrator.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3. Privilege Escalation within OpenProject [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Targets flaws in OpenProject's role-based access control (RBAC) or API authorization, allowing attackers to gain higher privileges than they are supposed to have. * 1.3.1. Exploiting Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) Weaknesses [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Attackers identify flaws in OpenProject's RBAC implementation. This could involve bypassing permission checks, exploiting misconfigurations in roles, or finding logic errors in how permissions are enforced. * Exploitation in OpenProject: By manipulating requests or exploiting vulnerabilities in the UI or API, an attacker might be able to elevate their privileges from a regular user to a project administrator or even a system administrator within OpenProject. * Impact: Unauthorized access to sensitive project data, ability to modify project settings, manipulate workflows, and potentially gain full control over the OpenProject instance.

        *   **1.3.2. API Abuse for Privilege Escalation (OpenProject API Specific) [HIGH-RISK PATH]**
        *   **Attack Vector:**  If the application uses OpenProject's API, attackers target API endpoints that might have insufficient authorization checks. They attempt to access API endpoints or manipulate API requests in a way that allows them to perform actions beyond their authorized privileges.
        *   **Exploitation in OpenProject:**  By crafting specific API requests, an attacker might be able to bypass authorization checks and perform actions like creating projects, modifying user roles, or accessing sensitive data through the API, even if they lack the necessary permissions in the UI.
        *   **Impact:** Similar to RBAC exploitation, leading to unauthorized access, data manipulation, and potential full control depending on the API vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.1. Exploiting Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) Weaknesses [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: Attackers identify flaws in OpenProject's RBAC implementation. This could involve bypassing permission checks, exploiting misconfigurations in roles, or finding logic errors in how permissions are enforced. * Exploitation in OpenProject: By manipulating requests or exploiting vulnerabilities in the UI or API, an attacker might be able to elevate their privileges from a regular user to a project administrator or even a system administrator within OpenProject. * Impact: Unauthorized access to sensitive project data, ability to modify project settings, manipulate workflows, and potentially gain full control over the OpenProject instance.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.2. API Abuse for Privilege Escalation (OpenProject API Specific) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: If the application uses OpenProject's API, attackers target API endpoints that might have insufficient authorization checks. They attempt to access API endpoints or manipulate API requests in a way that allows them to perform actions beyond their authorized privileges. * Exploitation in OpenProject: By crafting specific API requests, an attacker might be able to bypass authorization checks and perform actions like creating projects, modifying user roles, or accessing sensitive data through the API, even if they lack the necessary permissions in the UI. * Impact: Similar to RBAC exploitation, leading to unauthorized access, data manipulation, and potential full control depending on the API vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 2.1. SQL Injection in OpenProject Database Queries [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Targets vulnerabilities where user-supplied data is directly incorporated into SQL queries without proper sanitization, allowing attackers to manipulate database operations. * 2.1.1. Exploiting Vulnerable Search Functionality (OpenProject Search) [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Attackers inject malicious SQL code into search queries within OpenProject's search features (e.g., task search, wiki search, user search). If OpenProject's search functionality does not use parameterized queries or secure ORM practices, this injected SQL code can be executed by the database. * Exploitation in OpenProject: By crafting specific search terms containing SQL injection payloads, an attacker can bypass intended query logic and execute arbitrary SQL commands on the OpenProject database. * Impact: Database compromise. Attackers can read sensitive data from the database, modify data, or even potentially gain control of the database server itself, leading to full application compromise.

Attack Tree Path: 2.1.1. Exploiting Vulnerable Search Functionality (OpenProject Search) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: Attackers inject malicious SQL code into search queries within OpenProject's search features (e.g., task search, wiki search, user search). If OpenProject's search functionality does not use parameterized queries or secure ORM practices, this injected SQL code can be executed by the database. * Exploitation in OpenProject: By crafting specific search terms containing SQL injection payloads, an attacker can bypass intended query logic and execute arbitrary SQL commands on the OpenProject database. * Impact: Database compromise. Attackers can read sensitive data from the database, modify data, or even potentially gain control of the database server itself, leading to full application compromise.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) in OpenProject Features [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Targets vulnerabilities where user-supplied data is displayed to other users without proper encoding, allowing attackers to inject and execute malicious scripts in users' browsers. * 2.2.1. Stored XSS in Task Descriptions, Comments, Wiki Pages, Forum Posts [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: As described in 1.2.1, attackers inject malicious JavaScript code into user-generated content areas. This code is stored in the database and executed every time another user views the affected content. * Exploitation in OpenProject: If OpenProject fails to sanitize user inputs in these areas, stored XSS vulnerabilities become persistent. The malicious script can then be used to steal session cookies, redirect users to malicious sites, deface pages, or perform other actions in the context of the victim user's session. * Impact: Account takeover (via session cookie theft), defacement, phishing attacks, and potential further exploitation depending on the malicious script's capabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.1. Stored XSS in Task Descriptions, Comments, Wiki Pages, Forum Posts [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: As described in 1.2.1, attackers inject malicious JavaScript code into user-generated content areas. This code is stored in the database and executed every time another user views the affected content. * Exploitation in OpenProject: If OpenProject fails to sanitize user inputs in these areas, stored XSS vulnerabilities become persistent. The malicious script can then be used to steal session cookies, redirect users to malicious sites, deface pages, or perform other actions in the context of the victim user's session. * Impact: Account takeover (via session cookie theft), defacement, phishing attacks, and potential further exploitation depending on the malicious script's capabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 3.1. Known Vulnerabilities in Ruby on Rails Framework (If Applicable) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: OpenProject is built on Ruby on Rails. If the OpenProject instance is running on an outdated or vulnerable version of Rails, attackers can exploit known vulnerabilities in the framework itself. * Exploitation in OpenProject: Publicly disclosed vulnerabilities in Rails can be exploited to gain unauthorized access, execute arbitrary code, or bypass security controls within the OpenProject application. * Impact: Framework-level vulnerabilities can be severe, potentially leading to Remote Code Execution (RCE), complete server compromise, data breaches, and denial of service.

Attack Tree Path: 3.2. Vulnerabilities in Gems (Ruby Libraries) Used by OpenProject [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: OpenProject uses various Ruby libraries (gems). If any of these gems have known vulnerabilities, attackers can exploit them to compromise OpenProject. * Exploitation in OpenProject: Vulnerable gems can introduce various security flaws, including injection vulnerabilities, authentication bypasses, or RCE. Exploiting these vulnerabilities can allow attackers to gain control of the application or server. * Impact: Similar to Rails vulnerabilities, gem vulnerabilities can lead to a wide range of impacts, including RCE, data breaches, and denial of service, depending on the specific vulnerability and the affected gem's role in OpenProject.

Attack Tree Path: 5.1. Unrestricted File Upload leading to Remote Code Execution [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector: If OpenProject allows users to upload files without proper validation of file types and content, attackers can upload malicious files, such as web shells (e.g., PHP, JSP, ASPX scripts). * Exploitation in OpenProject: By uploading a web shell and accessing it through the web server, an attacker can execute arbitrary code on the server hosting OpenProject. * Impact: Remote Code Execution (RCE). Full server compromise. The attacker gains complete control over the server, allowing them to access sensitive data, install malware, pivot to other systems, and disrupt application availability.