Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
85 lines (66 loc) · 6.71 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

85 lines (66 loc) · 6.71 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for thoughtbot/paperclip

Mitigation Strategy: File Signature Validation (Magic Numbers) within Paperclip Validation

Description:

  1. Integrate a Gem: Add a gem like filemagic to your Gemfile and run bundle install.
  2. Create a Validation Method: In your model (e.g., User with an avatar attachment), define a custom validation method (e.g., file_signature_matches).
  3. Access Queued File: Inside the validation, access the file queued for writing: avatar.queued_for_write[:original]. This is the temporary file before Paperclip's processing.
  4. Use FileMagic: Use FileMagic to open the temporary file and determine its true MIME type based on its content (magic numbers).
  5. Whitelist Allowed Types: Define a strict whitelist of allowed MIME types (e.g., ['image/jpeg', 'image/png', 'image/gif']).
  6. Compare and Add Errors: Compare the detected MIME type against your whitelist. If it's not on the list, add an error to the model: errors.add(:avatar, "is not a valid file type").
  7. Ensure FileMagic is Closed: Close the FileMagic instance in an ensure block to release resources.
  8. Call the Validation: Use validate :file_signature_matches in your model to ensure the custom validation is executed.
  9. Combine with Paperclip's content_type: Keep Paperclip's content_type validation, but treat it as a secondary check. The file signature validation is the primary defense.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • MIME Type Spoofing: (Severity: High) - Attackers upload malicious files disguised as images by changing extensions or manipulating the Content-Type header.
  • File Type Confusion Attacks: (Severity: High) - Exploits relying on the server misinterpreting the file type.
  • Bypassing Basic Paperclip Validation: (Severity: High) - Paperclip's built-in MIME type validation is easily bypassed.

Impact:

  • MIME Type Spoofing: Risk significantly reduced. Prevents processing based on a false MIME type.
  • File Type Confusion Attacks: Risk significantly reduced. Accurate file type identification prevents misinterpretation.
  • Bypassing Basic Paperclip Validation: Risk significantly reduced. Provides a robust alternative.

Currently Implemented: Partially. filemagic is installed, and a basic validation exists in User, but it only checks image/jpeg and lacks proper error handling.

Missing Implementation:

  • Expand the User model validation to include all allowed types (PNG, GIF).
  • Add proper error handling (closing FileMagic in an ensure block).
  • Apply the validation to all models with Paperclip attachments.

Mitigation Strategy: Paperclip size Validation (as a Secondary Check)

Description:

  1. In Model Configuration: Within your has_attached_file declaration in your model, use the :size option.
  2. Specify a Range: Define a reasonable file size range, e.g., size: { in: 0..5.megabytes }. This should be smaller than any server-level limits.
  3. Treat as Secondary: Understand that this is a secondary check. The primary defense should be at the web server level (Nginx/Apache).

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large Files: (Severity: High) - Attackers upload large files to consume resources.
  • Resource Exhaustion: (Severity: High) - Similar to DoS, but can occur with moderately large files.

Impact:

  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large Files: Risk partially reduced. Provides a secondary layer of defense if the web server limit is bypassed or misconfigured.
  • Resource Exhaustion: Risk partially reduced. Helps limit resource consumption, but the web server limit is crucial.

Currently Implemented: Yes. The Paperclip :size validation is implemented in all relevant models.

Missing Implementation: None, within the context of Paperclip itself. The crucial missing piece is the web server configuration (which is outside the scope of this revised list).

Mitigation Strategy: Randomized Filenames within Paperclip

Description:

  1. before_post_process Callback: In your model, use a before_post_process callback (e.g., before_post_process :randomize_filename).
  2. Generate UUID: Inside the callback, generate a UUID using SecureRandom.uuid.
  3. Get File Extension: Extract the original file extension: File.extname(avatar_file_name).downcase.
  4. Combine UUID and Extension: Create the new filename: #{SecureRandom.uuid}#{extension}.
  5. Set file_name: Set the Paperclip file_name attribute: avatar.instance_write(:file_name, new_filename). This is crucial to do before Paperclip processes the file.
  6. Paperclip :path and :url: Configure Paperclip's :path and :url options to use interpolation of safe values (like :id, :style, and a generated :hash using a hash_secret). Never include user-provided data directly. Example: 
    has_attached_file :avatar,
                  path: ":rails_root/public/system/:attachment/:id/:style/:hash.:extension",
                  url: "/system/:attachment/:id/:style/:hash.:extension",
                  hash_secret: "a_long_random_secret"
  7. Store Original (Sanitized): If you need the original filename, store it in a separate database column (e.g., original_file_name) and sanitize it thoroughly before saving.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Directory Traversal: (Severity: High) - Attackers use crafted filenames (e.g., ../../etc/passwd) to write to arbitrary locations.
  • File Overwrite: (Severity: High) - Attackers upload files with the same name as existing files.
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Filenames: (Severity: Medium) - If filenames are displayed without escaping, they could contain malicious JavaScript.

Impact:

  • Directory Traversal: Risk eliminated. Randomized filenames prevent control over the file path.
  • File Overwrite: Risk significantly reduced. UUIDs ensure unique filenames.
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): Risk reduced (if combined with proper output encoding and sanitization of the stored original filename).

Currently Implemented: No. The application uses the original filename.

Missing Implementation:

  • Add the before_post_process callback to all models with Paperclip attachments.
  • Update Paperclip's :path and :url options.
  • Add a new database column (original_file_name) and update logic to store and sanitize the original filename.