Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
120 lines (90 loc) · 11.1 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

120 lines (90 loc) · 11.1 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for toptal/chewy

Objective: Compromise Application via Chewy Exploitation (Focus on High-Risk Vectors)

Attack Tree Visualization

0. [CRITICAL NODE] Compromise Application via Chewy Exploitation [HIGH RISK PATH START]
    ├── 1. [CRITICAL NODE] Exploit Elasticsearch Injection Vulnerabilities [HIGH RISK PATH START]
    │   ├── 1.1. [CRITICAL NODE] Unsanitized User Input in Search Queries [HIGH RISK PATH START]
    │   │   ├── 1.1.1. [CRITICAL NODE] Parameter Injection in Chewy Query DSL [HIGH RISK PATH START]
    │   │   │   ├── 1.1.1.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Modify Search Conditions to Bypass Authorization
    │   │   │   └── 1.1.1.2. [HIGH RISK PATH] Retrieve Sensitive Data via Modified Queries
    │   └── 1.2. [CRITICAL NODE] Insecure Query Construction Practices [HIGH RISK PATH START]
    │       ├── 1.2.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] String Interpolation/Concatenation for Query Building
    │       │   ├── 1.2.1.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Inject Elasticsearch Operators via String Manipulation
    │       └── 1.2.2. [HIGH RISK PATH] Lack of Input Validation/Sanitization before Querying
    │           ├── 1.2.2.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Pass Unvalidated User Input Directly to Chewy Queries
    ├── 2. Exploit Data Injection during Indexing
    │   ├── 2.1. Unsanitized Data Indexed into Elasticsearch
    │   │   ├── 2.1.1. Stored Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Indexed Data
    │   │   │   ├── 2.1.1.2. [HIGH RISK PATH] Trigger XSS when Displaying Search Results
    ├── 4. Information Disclosure via Search API Misuse
    │   ├── 4.1. Overly Permissive Search API
    │   │   ├── 4.1.1. Lack of Proper Authorization on Search Endpoints
    │   │   │   ├── 4.1.1.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Access Sensitive Data Intended for Authorized Users Only

Attack Tree Path: 0. [CRITICAL NODE] Compromise Application via Chewy Exploitation [HIGH RISK PATH START]

  • Description: The attacker aims to gain unauthorized access, control, or disrupt the application by exploiting vulnerabilities specifically related to its use of the Chewy gem for Elasticsearch integration. This is the root goal and encompasses all subsequent high-risk paths.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Prioritize security measures for all attack vectors listed under this root node, especially those marked as high-risk.
    • Implement a layered security approach to defend against various attack types.
    • Conduct regular security assessments and penetration testing focusing on Chewy integration.

Attack Tree Path: 1. [CRITICAL NODE] Exploit Elasticsearch Injection Vulnerabilities [HIGH RISK PATH START]

  • Description: This is the most critical threat. If user input is not properly sanitized and escaped before being used in Elasticsearch queries constructed by Chewy, it can lead to Elasticsearch injection. This is analogous to SQL injection and is a primary high-risk area.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Always sanitize and validate user input: Treat all user-provided data as potentially malicious.
    • Use Parameterized Queries: Utilize Chewy's mechanisms for parameterized queries to separate query structure from user data. Avoid string interpolation or concatenation.
    • Use Chewy's Query DSL Safely: Understand Chewy's Query DSL and use it correctly. Be cautious with raw query DSL if it involves user input.
    • Principle of Least Privilege: Grant the application user in Elasticsearch only necessary permissions.
    • Regular Security Audits: Review code constructing Chewy queries for injection vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1. [CRITICAL NODE] Unsanitized User Input in Search Queries [HIGH RISK PATH START]

  • Description: The application directly incorporates user input into search queries without proper sanitization, making it vulnerable to Elasticsearch injection. This is a direct cause of high-risk injection paths.
  • Actionable Insights: See insights for "1. Exploit Elasticsearch Injection Vulnerabilities".

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.1. [CRITICAL NODE] Parameter Injection in Chewy Query DSL [HIGH RISK PATH START]

  • Description: Attacker injects malicious parameters into Chewy's Query DSL (e.g., in where, filter clauses) when user input is used to build these parameters without sanitization. This is a specific and likely method of Elasticsearch injection.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Use Chewy's parameterized query methods: Chewy provides methods that handle parameterization.
    • Validate input against expected types and formats: Ensure user input conforms to what is expected for the search field.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.1.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Modify Search Conditions to Bypass Authorization

  • Description: By injecting parameters, an attacker can alter search conditions to bypass intended access controls and retrieve data they shouldn't see. This is a high-risk outcome of parameter injection.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Implement robust authorization checks before querying Elasticsearch. Don't rely solely on Elasticsearch queries for authorization.
    • Design queries to be inherently secure: Structure queries to only retrieve data the user is authorized to access, even if injection attempts occur.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.1.2. [HIGH RISK PATH] Retrieve Sensitive Data via Modified Queries

  • Description: Attacker modifies queries to extract sensitive data that should not be publicly accessible. This is a direct and high-impact consequence of successful parameter injection.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Minimize indexing of sensitive data. Only index data necessary for search functionality.
    • Implement field-level security in Elasticsearch (if applicable and needed).
    • Regularly review indexed data and access patterns.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2. [CRITICAL NODE] Insecure Query Construction Practices [HIGH RISK PATH START]

  • Description: Poor coding practices in building Chewy queries, specifically string interpolation/concatenation and lack of input validation, significantly increase Elasticsearch injection risks. These practices are direct contributors to high-risk injection paths.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Enforce secure coding standards: Train developers on secure query construction practices.
    • Code Reviews: Implement mandatory code reviews focusing on Chewy query construction.
    • Automated Security Checks: Use static analysis tools to detect insecure query patterns.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] String Interpolation/Concatenation for Query Building

  • Description: Using string interpolation or concatenation to embed user input directly into query strings is a classic and highly likely injection vulnerability in Chewy context.
  • Actionable Insights: Never use string interpolation or concatenation to build Chewy queries with user input. Always use parameterized query methods or safe query builders.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Inject Elasticsearch Operators via String Manipulation

  • Description: Attacker injects Elasticsearch operators by manipulating strings used to build queries when string interpolation/concatenation is used. This is a direct exploit of insecure query construction.
  • Actionable Insights: Avoid string manipulation for query construction.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.2. [HIGH RISK PATH] Lack of Input Validation/Sanitization before Querying

  • Description: Failing to validate and sanitize user input before using it in Chewy queries is a fundamental security flaw leading to high-risk injection vulnerabilities.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all user-provided data used in search queries.
    • Use a whitelist approach for allowed characters and formats if possible.
    • Escape special characters relevant to Elasticsearch query syntax.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.2.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Pass Unvalidated User Input Directly to Chewy Queries

  • Description: Directly passing user input to Chewy query methods without any validation or sanitization is the most direct and easily exploitable instance of lacking input validation, leading to high injection risk.
  • Actionable Insights: Always validate and sanitize user input.

Attack Tree Path: 2.1.1.2. [HIGH RISK PATH] Trigger XSS when Displaying Search Results

  • Description: XSS is triggered when search results containing malicious JavaScript (injected during indexing due to lack of sanitization) are displayed to users. While impact is medium, the likelihood is high if indexing sanitization is missing and output encoding is not properly implemented during display.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Sanitize data for HTML output encoding before indexing.
    • Sanitize output when displaying search results as a defense-in-depth measure. Use templating engines that automatically escape output.
    • Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement CSP to mitigate the impact of potential XSS vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 4.1.1.1. [HIGH RISK PATH] Access Sensitive Data Intended for Authorized Users Only

  • Description: Unauthorized users can access sensitive data through search due to lack of proper authorization on search endpoints. This is a high-risk information disclosure scenario.
  • Actionable Insights:
    • Implement proper authorization for search endpoints. Ensure only authorized users can access specific search functionalities and data.
    • Principle of Least Privilege for Search APIs: Expose only the necessary search functionality and data to users.
    • Regularly review and test authorization rules for search APIs.