Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
124 lines (93 loc) · 9.7 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

124 lines (93 loc) · 9.7 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for toptal/chewy

Mitigation Strategy: Chewy Version Compatibility and Updates

Description:

  1. Identify Supported Versions: Consult Chewy's documentation (README, release notes) to determine the officially supported Elasticsearch versions.
  2. Check Current Chewy Version: Determine the currently installed version of Chewy.
  3. Upgrade Planning: If Chewy is outdated, plan an upgrade. Prioritize security updates.
  4. Staging Environment: Test upgrades in a staging environment that mirrors production.
  5. Upgrade Staging: Upgrade Chewy in the staging environment.
  6. Testing: Thoroughly test all Chewy-related functionality in staging, including indexing, searching, updating, and any custom logic. Perform regression testing.
  7. Production Upgrade: If staging tests are successful, upgrade the production environment.
  8. Monitoring: After the upgrade, closely monitor Chewy for any issues.
  9. Regular Updates: Establish a schedule for regularly checking for and applying updates to Chewy.
  10. Dependency Management: Use a dependency management tool (e.g., Bundler for Ruby) to manage Chewy and its dependencies, including the Elasticsearch client. Ensure the Elasticsearch client is compatible with the target Elasticsearch version, as specified by Chewy.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Vulnerabilities in Outdated Chewy: (Severity: Medium) - Exploitation of vulnerabilities in older Chewy versions, potentially leading to data leaks or denial of service.
  • Incompatibility Issues: (Severity: Medium) - Unexpected behavior or errors due to incompatibility between Chewy and Elasticsearch versions, specifically related to how Chewy interacts with newer/older features.

Impact:

  • Vulnerabilities in Outdated Chewy: Risk significantly reduced by keeping Chewy up-to-date.
  • Incompatibility Issues: Risk eliminated by ensuring compatibility through Chewy's supported versions.

Currently Implemented:

  • Chewy version is checked during deployment (CI/CD pipeline).
  • Basic automated tests cover Chewy functionality.

Missing Implementation:

  • No formal schedule for regular security updates of Chewy.
  • No monitoring specifically for Chewy/Elasticsearch compatibility issues from Chewy's perspective.

Mitigation Strategy: Query Injection Prevention (Direct Chewy Usage)

Description:

  1. Avoid Raw Queries: Always use Chewy's query DSL methods (e.g., query, filter, term, match) to construct queries programmatically. These methods are designed to handle escaping and parameterization correctly, preventing injection vulnerabilities within the context of how Chewy builds the query.
  2. Code Review: Carefully review any code that constructs Elasticsearch queries using Chewy, paying close attention to how user input is handled before it's passed to Chewy's methods.
  3. Avoid Eval: Never use eval or similar functions with user input in any part of the Chewy query construction process.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Elasticsearch Query Injection (via Chewy): (Severity: High) - Attackers manipulating Elasticsearch queries constructed by Chewy to access unauthorized data or execute arbitrary code.

Impact:

  • Elasticsearch Query Injection (via Chewy): Risk significantly reduced by always using Chewy's DSL and avoiding direct embedding of user input into Chewy's methods.

Currently Implemented:

  • Chewy's query DSL methods are used for most queries.

Missing Implementation:

  • A few older parts of the application still use raw query strings passed to Chewy with insufficient validation and escaping.
  • No formal code review process specifically focuses on query injection vulnerabilities within the Chewy interaction.

Mitigation Strategy: Denial of Service (DoS) Prevention (Chewy-Specific Actions)

Description:

  1. Bulk Indexing Optimization: Use Chewy's bulk indexing features responsibly. Choose appropriate batch sizes within Chewy's configuration based on testing and monitoring. Implement error handling for bulk operations within the code using Chewy.
  2. Query Optimization: Optimize Chewy queries for performance. Avoid overly broad or complex queries constructed using Chewy's DSL. Use filters and aggregations efficiently within Chewy's API. Profile queries generated by Chewy to identify bottlenecks.
  3. update_index and atomic Review: Carefully review the use of Chewy's update_index and atomic update methods. Ensure they are used judiciously and efficiently. Consider alternatives if they are causing performance issues due to how Chewy handles these operations.
  4. Timeout Configuration: Set appropriate timeouts for Chewy operations (e.g., within the Chewy configuration or when calling Chewy methods) to prevent long-running requests from blocking resources.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Resource Exhaustion (DoS) (via Chewy): (Severity: High) - Attackers overwhelming the Elasticsearch cluster with excessive requests initiated through Chewy, causing a denial of service.
  • Performance Degradation (via Chewy): (Severity: Medium) - Slow response times due to inefficient queries or excessive load caused by how Chewy is used.

Impact:

  • Resource Exhaustion/Performance Degradation (via Chewy): Risk significantly reduced by implementing optimized Chewy usage, batching, and timeouts within the application's interaction with Chewy.

Currently Implemented:

  • Some query optimization within Chewy's DSL has been performed.

Missing Implementation:

  • No systematic review of update_index and atomic usage within Chewy.
  • Timeouts are not consistently configured for Chewy operations.
  • Batch sizes for bulk indexing are not optimized based on Chewy's performance.

Mitigation Strategy: Dependency Vulnerability Management (Chewy and its Direct Dependencies)

Description:

  1. Vulnerability Scanning: Use a dependency vulnerability scanner (e.g., Bundler-audit, Dependabot, Snyk) to regularly scan Chewy itself and its direct dependencies (including the Elasticsearch client library it uses) for known vulnerabilities.
  2. Update Chewy: Keep Chewy up to date. Prioritize security updates.
  3. Update Dependencies: Keep Chewy's direct dependencies up to date.
  4. Pin Dependency Versions: Pin Chewy and its dependency versions to specific, known-good versions to prevent unexpected changes from introducing vulnerabilities. Use a lockfile (e.g., Gemfile.lock for Ruby).
  5. Alerting: Configure the vulnerability scanner to send alerts when new vulnerabilities are found in Chewy or its direct dependencies.
  6. Remediation Process: Establish a process for promptly addressing identified vulnerabilities, including patching, upgrading, or mitigating the risk.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Vulnerabilities in Chewy: (Severity: Medium to High) - Exploitation of vulnerabilities in the Chewy gem itself.
  • Vulnerabilities in Chewy's Dependencies: (Severity: Medium to High) - Exploitation of vulnerabilities in Chewy's direct dependencies, such as the Elasticsearch client library it uses.

Impact:

  • Vulnerabilities in Chewy/Dependencies: Risk significantly reduced by regularly scanning for and addressing vulnerabilities.

Currently Implemented:

  • Dependabot is enabled for the project.

Missing Implementation:

  • No formal process for promptly addressing vulnerabilities reported by Dependabot specifically for Chewy and its direct dependencies.
  • Dependency versions are not always strictly pinned.

Mitigation Strategy: Observability and Auditing (Chewy-Specific Logging)

Description:

  1. Chewy Logging: Enable detailed logging within Chewy. Configure the log level to capture relevant information, including indexing operations, search queries, updates, and errors. This provides direct insight into Chewy's actions.
  2. Centralized Logging: Ensure Chewy's logs are sent to a centralized logging system.
  3. Monitoring Dashboards: Create monitoring dashboards to visualize key Chewy-specific metrics, such as Chewy operation counts, error rates.
  4. Alerting: Configure alerts for suspicious activity observable through Chewy's logs, such as high error rates or unusual query patterns generated by Chewy.
  5. Regular Log Review: Regularly review Chewy's logs to identify potential security issues, performance bottlenecks, and operational problems.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Lack of Visibility (into Chewy): (Severity: Medium) - Difficulty in detecting and responding to security incidents due to insufficient logging of Chewy's operations.
  • Performance Issues (within Chewy): (Severity: Medium) - Difficulty in diagnosing and resolving performance problems related to Chewy's usage.

Impact:

  • Lack of Visibility/Performance Issues (within Chewy): Improved detection and response capabilities, leading to reduced risk.

Currently Implemented:

  • Basic logging is enabled in Chewy.

Missing Implementation:

  • Chewy logging is not sufficiently detailed to capture all relevant operations.
  • No dedicated monitoring dashboards for Chewy-specific metrics.
  • Alerting is not configured for suspicious activity related to Chewy's logs.
  • No regular log review process is in place specifically for Chewy's logs.