Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
259 lines (231 loc) · 15.5 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

259 lines (231 loc) · 15.5 KB

BUSINESS POSTURE

  • Business priorities and goals:
    • Provide a robust, reliable, and user-friendly command-line argument parsing library for Rust developers.
    • Enable Rust developers to easily build command-line interfaces for their applications.
    • Maintain a widely adopted and trusted library within the Rust ecosystem.
  • Most important business risks:
    • Risk of bugs or vulnerabilities in the library leading to issues in applications that depend on it.
    • Risk of performance issues impacting the usability of applications using the library.
    • Risk of lack of maintenance or community support leading to stagnation and reduced adoption.

SECURITY POSTURE

  • Existing security controls:
    • security control: Open source development model, allowing for community review and contribution, hosted on GitHub.
    • security control: Use of Rust programming language, which provides memory safety and reduces certain classes of vulnerabilities.
    • security control: Comprehensive suite of unit and integration tests to ensure functionality and catch regressions, described in repository's test suite.
    • security control: Code review process via GitHub pull requests before merging changes, visible in repository's pull request history.
  • Accepted risks:
    • accepted risk: Reliance on community contributions for identifying and addressing security vulnerabilities.
    • accepted risk: Potential for vulnerabilities in dependencies that clap-rs/clap relies upon.
  • Recommended security controls:
    • security control: Implement automated Static Application Security Testing (SAST) tools in the Continuous Integration (CI) pipeline to detect potential vulnerabilities in code changes.
    • security control: Consider incorporating dependency scanning tools to identify known vulnerabilities in third-party libraries used by clap-rs/clap.
    • security control: Establish a clear process for reporting and handling security vulnerabilities, including a security policy and contact information.
  • Security requirements:
    • Authentication: Not applicable for a library. Clap-rs/clap itself does not handle user authentication.
    • Authorization: Not applicable for a library. Clap-rs/clap itself does not handle user authorization.
    • Input validation: Critical. Clap-rs/clap must robustly validate and sanitize command-line arguments to prevent unexpected behavior, crashes, or vulnerabilities in applications using it. This is implicitly part of the library's core functionality.
    • Cryptography: Not directly applicable. Clap-rs/clap itself is not expected to perform cryptographic operations. However, applications using clap-rs/clap might handle sensitive data, and clap-rs/clap should not introduce vulnerabilities that could compromise such data if passed as arguments (though passing sensitive data as command line arguments is generally discouraged).

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

flowchart LR
    subgraph Internet
        A("Crates.io")
    end
    subgraph Developer Workstation
        B("Rust Developer")
    end
    C("clap-rs/clap Library")
    D("Rust Toolchain")
    E("Applications using clap-rs/clap")

    B --> C
    C --> D
    C --> A
    D --> A
    C --> E
    E --> D

    linkStyle 0,1,2,3,4,5 stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px;
Loading
  • Elements of context diagram:
      • Name: Rust Developer
      • Type: Person
      • Description: Software developers who use the clap-rs/clap library to build command-line applications in Rust.
      • Responsibilities: Utilize clap-rs/clap to define and parse command-line arguments for their applications. Report issues and contribute to the library.
      • Security controls: Secure development practices on their workstations.
      • Name: clap-rs/clap Library
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: A Rust library for parsing command-line arguments. It is the central component of this design document.
      • Responsibilities: Provide a robust and flexible API for defining and parsing command-line arguments. Ensure correct and safe parsing of user inputs.
      • Security controls: Input validation, secure coding practices, automated testing, community review.
      • Name: Rust Toolchain
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: The Rust compiler (rustc), package manager (Cargo), and standard library. Essential for building and using Rust libraries.
      • Responsibilities: Compile Rust code, manage dependencies, provide core functionalities for Rust programs.
      • Security controls: Security of the Rust toolchain itself, which is maintained by the Rust project.
      • Name: Crates.io
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: The official package registry for Rust crates (libraries). Used to distribute and download clap-rs/clap.
      • Responsibilities: Host and distribute Rust crates. Ensure integrity and availability of packages.
      • Security controls: Security measures implemented by Crates.io to protect packages and user accounts.
      • Name: Applications using clap-rs/clap
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: Various command-line applications built by Rust developers that depend on the clap-rs/clap library.
      • Responsibilities: Utilize clap-rs/clap to handle command-line argument parsing. Implement application-specific logic.
      • Security controls: Application-specific security controls, including how they handle arguments parsed by clap-rs/clap.

C4 CONTAINER

flowchart LR
    subgraph Developer Workstation
        A("Rust Developer")
    end
    B("clap-rs/clap Library Code")
    C("Cargo Build System")
    D("Unit and Integration Tests")
    E("crates.io Publishing")

    A --> B
    B --> C
    C --> D
    C --> E

    linkStyle 0,1,2,3 stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px;
Loading
  • Elements of container diagram:
      • Name: clap-rs/clap Library Code
      • Type: Container (Code Repository)
      • Description: The source code of the clap-rs/clap library, written in Rust and hosted on GitHub.
      • Responsibilities: Implement the command-line argument parsing logic. Maintain code quality, security, and functionality.
      • Security controls: Version control (Git), code review process, static analysis (planned), vulnerability scanning (planned).
      • Name: Cargo Build System
      • Type: Container (Build Tool)
      • Description: Rust's build system and package manager. Used to compile, test, and package the clap-rs/clap library.
      • Responsibilities: Compile the Rust code, manage dependencies, run tests, create distributable packages.
      • Security controls: Dependency management, build reproducibility, potentially build signing (not currently implemented for clap-rs/clap publishing process as visible in repository).
      • Name: Unit and Integration Tests
      • Type: Container (Testing Framework)
      • Description: Automated tests written to verify the functionality and correctness of the clap-rs/clap library.
      • Responsibilities: Ensure code quality, detect regressions, validate input parsing logic.
      • Security controls: Test coverage, regular execution in CI, security-focused test cases (e.g., testing for input validation vulnerabilities).
      • Name: crates.io Publishing
      • Type: Container (Distribution System)
      • Description: Process of packaging and uploading the compiled clap-rs/clap library to Crates.io for public distribution.
      • Responsibilities: Make the library available to Rust developers. Ensure integrity of published packages.
      • Security controls: Crates.io security controls, potentially signing of packages (not currently implemented for clap-rs/clap publishing process as visible in repository), secure publishing process (using API keys, etc.).

DEPLOYMENT

flowchart LR
    subgraph Developer Environment
        A("Developer Workstation")
        B("Cargo Build Tool")
    end
    subgraph Crates.io Registry
        C("Crates.io Server")
        D("clap-rs/clap Package")
    end
    subgraph User Application Deployment Environment
        E("User Application Server/Environment")
        F("Application using clap-rs/clap")
    end

    A --> B: Build & Publish
    B --> C: Publish
    C --> D: Stores
    C --> E: Download
    E --> F: Uses

    linkStyle 0,1,2,3,4 stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px;
Loading
  • Elements of deployment diagram:
      • Name: Developer Workstation
      • Type: Infrastructure (Physical/Virtual Machine)
      • Description: The development machine used by Rust developers to build and publish the clap-rs/clap library.
      • Responsibilities: Development, testing, building, and publishing of the library.
      • Security controls: Developer workstation security practices, access control, secure development environment.
      • Name: Cargo Build Tool
      • Type: Software
      • Description: Rust's build tool used on the developer workstation to compile and package the library.
      • Responsibilities: Building the library, managing dependencies, packaging for distribution.
      • Security controls: Secure build process, dependency integrity checks.
      • Name: Crates.io Server
      • Type: Infrastructure (Server)
      • Description: The servers hosting the Crates.io registry, responsible for storing and distributing Rust crates.
      • Responsibilities: Hosting and serving Rust crates, managing package metadata, user accounts, and API access.
      • Security controls: Crates.io infrastructure security, access control, DDoS protection, package integrity checks.
      • Name: clap-rs/clap Package
      • Type: Data (Software Package)
      • Description: The packaged and published version of the clap-rs/clap library stored on Crates.io.
      • Responsibilities: Provide the distributable artifact of the library.
      • Security controls: Package integrity (checksums, potentially signing - not currently implemented for clap-rs/clap publishing process as visible in repository), Crates.io security measures.
      • Name: User Application Server/Environment
      • Type: Infrastructure (Server/Environment)
      • Description: The environment where applications using clap-rs/clap are deployed and run. This could be various environments like servers, desktops, cloud instances, etc.
      • Responsibilities: Run applications that depend on clap-rs/clap.
      • Security controls: Environment-specific security controls, application security controls.
      • Name: Application using clap-rs/clap
      • Type: Software
      • Description: An application built by a Rust developer that uses the clap-rs/clap library for command-line argument parsing.
      • Responsibilities: Utilize clap-rs/clap for argument parsing, implement application logic.
      • Security controls: Application-specific security controls, secure handling of arguments parsed by clap-rs/clap.

BUILD

flowchart LR
    A("Developer") --> B("Code Commit to GitHub");
    B --> C("GitHub Actions CI");
    C --> D("Build & Test");
    D --> E("Linters & SAST (Recommended)");
    E --> F("Package & Publish to Crates.io");
    F --> G("crates.io Artifact");

    style A fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style G fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

    linkStyle 0,1,2,3,4,5 stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px;
Loading
  • Elements of build diagram:
      • Name: Developer
      • Type: Person
      • Description: A software developer contributing to the clap-rs/clap project.
      • Responsibilities: Writing code, fixing bugs, adding features, and committing changes to the GitHub repository.
      • Security controls: Secure coding practices, code review participation, workstation security.
      • Name: Code Commit to GitHub
      • Type: Process
      • Description: The action of committing code changes to the clap-rs/clap GitHub repository.
      • Responsibilities: Version control, change tracking, triggering the CI pipeline.
      • Security controls: GitHub access controls, branch protection rules, commit signing (not enforced but possible).
      • Name: GitHub Actions CI
      • Type: System (CI/CD)
      • Description: GitHub's built-in Continuous Integration and Continuous Delivery service, used to automate the build, test, and publishing process for clap-rs/clap.
      • Responsibilities: Automate build, test, and potentially deployment workflows.
      • Security controls: GitHub Actions security best practices, secrets management, workflow definition security.
      • Name: Build & Test
      • Type: Process
      • Description: The automated process of compiling the Rust code and running unit and integration tests.
      • Responsibilities: Ensure code compiles correctly and tests pass, verifying functionality.
      • Security controls: Secure build environment, dependency integrity checks during build, test isolation.
      • Name: Linters & SAST (Recommended)
      • Type: Process (Security Check)
      • Description: Recommended addition to the build process to include automated code linters and Static Application Security Testing (SAST) tools to identify potential code quality and security issues.
      • Responsibilities: Improve code quality, identify potential vulnerabilities early in the development lifecycle.
      • Security controls: SAST tool configuration, integration with CI pipeline, vulnerability reporting.
      • Name: Package & Publish to Crates.io
      • Type: Process
      • Description: The automated process of packaging the compiled library and publishing it to the Crates.io registry.
      • Responsibilities: Distribute the library to Rust developers via Crates.io.
      • Security controls: Secure publishing process (API keys management), package integrity (checksums, potentially signing - not currently implemented for clap-rs/clap publishing process as visible in repository), Crates.io security controls.
      • Name: crates.io Artifact
      • Type: Data (Software Package)
      • Description: The final packaged and published clap-rs/clap library available on Crates.io.
      • Responsibilities: Distributable artifact of the library.
      • Security controls: Crates.io security measures, package integrity.

RISK ASSESSMENT

  • Critical business process we are trying to protect:
    • Providing a reliable, secure, and functional command-line argument parsing library to the Rust community. The critical process is the development, build, and distribution of this library.
  • Data we are trying to protect and their sensitivity:
    • Source code: Publicly available on GitHub, but integrity and availability are important to prevent malicious modifications or disruptions.
    • Build artifacts (compiled library): Publicly available on Crates.io, integrity and availability are crucial to ensure users download legitimate and functional library versions.
    • Crates.io publishing credentials: Sensitive. Compromise could lead to malicious package uploads.
    • GitHub account credentials: Sensitive. Compromise could lead to code manipulation or repository takeover.

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

  • Questions:
    • What is the intended scope for threat modeling? Is it focused solely on the clap-rs/clap library itself, or does it extend to applications that use the library? (Assumption: Focus is primarily on the library itself).
    • Are there any specific security concerns or past incidents that are driving this design document and threat modeling exercise? (Assumption: This is a proactive security assessment, not triggered by a specific incident).
    • What is the acceptable risk level for the clap-rs/clap project? (Assumption: Aim for a low risk level given the library's wide usage and importance in the Rust ecosystem).
  • Assumptions:
    • The clap-rs/clap project aims to be a widely used and trusted library in the Rust ecosystem.
    • Security and reliability are important non-functional requirements for the clap-rs/clap library.
    • The primary distribution channel for clap-rs/clap is Crates.io.
    • The development and build infrastructure relies on GitHub and GitHub Actions.