Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
96 lines (76 loc) · 5.87 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

96 lines (76 loc) · 5.87 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for clap-rs/clap

Objective: To cause unintended application behavior, resource exhaustion, or information disclosure by manipulating command-line arguments processed by clap.

Attack Tree Visualization

                                      Attacker's Goal:
                                Cause Unintended Application Behavior,
                                Resource Exhaustion, or Information Disclosure
                                        via Clap Argument Manipulation
                                                  |
        -------------------------------------------------------------------------
        |                                               |
  Sub-Goal 1: [CRITICAL]                       Sub-Goal 2: [CRITICAL]
  Trigger Unexpected                          Cause Resource Exhaustion
  Application Logic
        |                                               |
  ---------------------                   ------------------------
  |                   |                   |
A2: Exploit [CRITICAL] B1: Overflow
Argument        Allocations/
Validation       Buffers [HIGH RISK]
Bypass
                 |
  --------------------------------
  |                              |
A2.1: Fuzz with      A2.2: Leverage [HIGH RISK]
Invalid Argument    Poorly Defined
Types/Values        Argument Constraints
[HIGH RISK]         (e.g., missing
                    range checks)
                                                  |
                                            Sub-Goal 3:
                                            Disclose Sensitive
                                            Information
                                                  |
                                            ---------------------
                                            |
                                            C1: Trigger Verbose/
                                            Debug Output [HIGH RISK]
                                            (if enabled)

Attack Tree Path: Sub-Goal 1: Trigger Unexpected Application Logic [CRITICAL]

  • Description: The attacker aims to make the application behave in ways not intended by the developers. This is a critical sub-goal because it encompasses a wide range of potential vulnerabilities and is often the starting point for more serious attacks. Weak argument validation is a primary enabler.

Attack Tree Path: A2: Exploit Argument Validation Bypass [CRITICAL]

  • Description: The attacker attempts to circumvent the validation checks implemented by the application, either those built into clap or custom validators. This is a critical node because it's the gateway to many specific vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: A2.1: Fuzz with Invalid Argument Types/Values [HIGH RISK]

  • Description: The attacker uses a fuzzer to send a large number of invalid or unexpected inputs to the application, targeting the argument parsing logic. This is high-risk due to the effectiveness of fuzzing in finding vulnerabilities, especially in custom validation code.
    • Likelihood: Medium to High
    • Impact: Medium to Very High (ranging from crashes to potential code execution)
    • Effort: Low to Medium
    • Skill Level: Intermediate
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard

Attack Tree Path: A2.2: Leverage Poorly Defined Argument Constraints [HIGH RISK]

  • Description: The attacker provides argument values that are technically valid according to clap's basic type checking but violate the intended constraints or assumptions of the application. This is high-risk because it's a very common developer oversight.
    • Likelihood: High
    • Impact: Low to Medium
    • Effort: Very Low
    • Skill Level: Novice
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: Sub-Goal 2: Cause Resource Exhaustion [CRITICAL]

  • Description: The attacker aims to consume excessive resources (CPU, memory), leading to a denial-of-service (DoS) condition. This is critical because it directly impacts application availability.

Attack Tree Path: B1: Overflow Allocations/Buffers [HIGH RISK]

  • Description: The attacker provides an argument value that is used to determine the size of a memory allocation. By providing a very large value, the attacker can trigger an overflow, leading to a crash or potentially other vulnerabilities. This is high-risk due to its potential for severe impact.
    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: High to Very High
    • Effort: Low
    • Skill Level: Intermediate
    • Detection Difficulty: Easy to Medium

Attack Tree Path: Sub-Goal 3: Disclose Sensitive Information

  • Description: The attacker aims to obtain sensitive information through argument manipulation.

Attack Tree Path: C1: Trigger Verbose/Debug Output (if enabled) [HIGH RISK]

  • Description: If the application has a verbosity flag (e.g., --verbose) and the verbose output contains sensitive information, the attacker can simply enable this flag to obtain the data. This is high risk because of the potential for significant data breaches.
    • Likelihood: Low to Medium
    • Impact: Medium to Very High
    • Effort: Very Low
    • Skill Level: Novice
    • Detection Difficulty: Very Easy