Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
49 lines (42 loc) · 4.87 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

49 lines (42 loc) · 4.87 KB

Threat Model Analysis for rayon-rs/rayon

Threat: Data Race Exploitation

  • Threat: Data Race Exploitation
  • Description: An attacker provides crafted input or manipulates the application's state in a way that triggers a data race within a Rayon parallel operation. This could involve rapidly changing shared data while a parallel computation is in progress, exploiting timing windows. The attacker aims to corrupt data used in security-critical decisions (e.g., authentication checks, authorization logic, data validation).
  • Impact: High to Critical. Data corruption can lead to privilege escalation, bypass of security controls, arbitrary code execution (if the corrupted data influences memory management), or denial of service.
  • Affected Rayon Component:
    • par_iter_mut(): Most vulnerable when operating on shared mutable data without proper synchronization.
    • par_iter(): Vulnerable if closures capture mutable references or interact with shared mutable state through unsafe code.
    • Any parallel construct (join, scope, custom thread pools) used with improperly synchronized shared mutable state.
  • Risk Severity: High to Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Immutable Data: Prefer immutable data structures for parallel computations.
    • Atomic Operations: Use std::sync::atomic types for shared counters or flags.
    • Mutexes/RwLocks: Use std::sync::Mutex or std::sync::RwLock to protect shared mutable data, ensuring locks are held only within the parallel closure and for the shortest possible duration.
    • rayon::scope: Use rayon::scope to create a structured parallel scope, ensuring that all spawned threads complete before the scope exits, simplifying lifetime management.
    • ThreadSanitizer: Run tests under ThreadSanitizer to detect data races during development.
    • Code Review: Thoroughly review code for potential data races, especially in sections using unsafe or shared mutable state.

Threat: Deadlock-Induced Denial of Service

  • Threat: Deadlock-Induced Denial of Service
  • Description: An attacker crafts input or manipulates the application's state to trigger a deadlock between Rayon-managed threads and other application threads, or within Rayon's internal thread pool. This typically involves holding locks across parallel operations or creating circular dependencies in lock acquisition.
  • Impact: High. The application becomes unresponsive, leading to a denial of service.
  • Affected Rayon Component:
    • Any Rayon parallel construct (par_iter, par_iter_mut, join, scope, custom thread pools) used in conjunction with external synchronization primitives (mutexes, etc.).
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Avoid Locks Across Parallel Operations: Do not hold locks (mutexes, etc.) across calls to Rayon's parallel iterators or functions. Acquire and release locks within the parallel closure.
    • Consistent Locking Order: If multiple locks are required, ensure a consistent locking order across all threads to prevent circular dependencies.
    • Minimize Lock Contention: Design the parallel logic to minimize the need for shared mutable state and lock contention.
    • Timeout Mechanisms: Consider using timeouts when acquiring locks to prevent indefinite blocking.

Threat: Resource Exhaustion (Thread/Memory) Denial of Service

  • Threat: Resource Exhaustion (Thread/Memory) Denial of Service
  • Description: An attacker provides a very large input dataset or triggers a computationally intensive operation that causes Rayon to create an excessive number of threads or allocate a large amount of memory. This overwhelms system resources, leading to a denial of service.
  • Impact: High. The application crashes or becomes unresponsive.
  • Affected Rayon Component:
    • All parallel constructs (par_iter, par_iter_mut, join, scope, etc.) are potentially affected, especially when processing unbounded input.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Bounded Thread Pool: Use rayon::ThreadPoolBuilder::new().num_threads(...) to create a thread pool with a fixed, limited number of threads.
    • Input Validation: Strictly validate the size and complexity of input data. Reject excessively large inputs.
    • Chunking: Use par_chunks or par_chunks_mut to process large datasets in smaller, manageable chunks.
    • Resource Monitoring: Monitor CPU, memory, and thread usage to detect and respond to potential resource exhaustion.
    • Adaptive Parallelism (Advanced): Consider techniques to dynamically adjust the level of parallelism based on system load.