Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
309 lines (271 loc) · 19.9 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

309 lines (271 loc) · 19.9 KB

BUSINESS POSTURE

  • Business Priorities and Goals:

    • Goal: To provide a reliable, efficient, and secure build system and package manager for the Rust programming language.
    • Goal: To foster a thriving Rust ecosystem by simplifying dependency management and project building for developers.
    • Goal: To ensure the integrity and availability of Rust packages (crates) for the community.
    • Priority: Developer productivity and ease of use.
    • Priority: Security and reliability of the build process and dependency resolution.
    • Priority: Stability and backwards compatibility to avoid disrupting the Rust ecosystem.

  • Business Risks:

    • Risk: Supply chain attacks through compromised dependencies or crates.io infrastructure.
    • Risk: Vulnerabilities in the cargo build system leading to compromised builds or developer machines.
    • Risk: Denial of service or instability of crates.io impacting Rust development workflows.
    • Risk: Accidental or malicious introduction of vulnerabilities in cargo itself.
    • Risk: Loss of trust in the Rust ecosystem due to security incidents related to cargo or crates.io.

SECURITY POSTURE

  • Existing Security Controls:

    • security control: Code review process for contributions to cargo, implemented in GitHub pull requests.
    • security control: Automated testing and continuous integration (CI) to detect regressions and potential vulnerabilities, implemented in GitHub Workflows.
    • security control: Rust's memory safety features mitigate certain classes of vulnerabilities. Described in Rust documentation and language design.
    • security control: Secure coding practices within the Rust project, implicitly followed by Rust developers.
    • security control: Use of HTTPS for communication with crates.io, implemented in cargo's network requests.
    • security control: Checksums and cryptographic signatures for crates published to crates.io, implemented in crates.io infrastructure and verified by cargo.
    • security control: Vulnerability reporting process for cargo and crates.io, described in Rust Security policy.
    • security control: Regular updates and maintenance of cargo and crates.io, implicitly followed by Rust team.

  • Accepted Risks:

    • accepted risk: Potential for vulnerabilities in dependencies used by cargo. Mitigation is through dependency review and updates.
    • accepted risk: Risk of user error in configuring cargo or writing build scripts. Mitigation is through clear documentation and error messages.
    • accepted risk: Reliance on the security of crates.io infrastructure, which is a separate project. Mitigation is through monitoring and collaboration with crates.io team.

  • Recommended Security Controls:

    • security control: Implement static analysis security testing (SAST) tools in the CI pipeline to automatically detect potential vulnerabilities in cargo code.
    • security control: Implement dependency scanning tools to identify known vulnerabilities in cargo's dependencies.
    • security control: Consider fuzz testing to discover unexpected behavior and potential vulnerabilities in cargo's parsing and processing logic.
    • security control: Formalize security training for cargo developers to reinforce secure coding practices.
    • security control: Implement a more detailed threat model for cargo to proactively identify and mitigate potential security risks.
    • security control: Enhance supply chain security by using signed commits and provenance information for cargo releases.

  • Security Requirements:

    • Authentication:
      • Requirement: Cargo needs to authenticate users when publishing crates to crates.io. Implemented by crates.io authentication mechanisms (API keys, tokens).
      • Requirement: Securely store and manage authentication credentials used by developers for publishing. Responsibility of developers and their systems.
    • Authorization:
      • Requirement: Crates.io needs to authorize users to publish crates under specific namespaces. Implemented by crates.io authorization system.
      • Requirement: Cargo needs to respect crates.io authorization policies when publishing and accessing crates. Implemented in cargo's interaction with crates.io API.
    • Input Validation:
      • Requirement: Cargo must validate all inputs, including command-line arguments, configuration files (Cargo.toml), and responses from crates.io, to prevent injection attacks and unexpected behavior. Implemented throughout cargo's codebase.
      • Requirement: Robust parsing and validation of crate metadata and dependency specifications to prevent malicious crates from exploiting vulnerabilities. Implemented in cargo's dependency resolution and metadata handling logic.
    • Cryptography:
      • Requirement: Use cryptography to verify the integrity and authenticity of downloaded crates. Implemented by cargo verifying checksums and signatures provided by crates.io.
      • Requirement: Securely handle cryptographic keys used for signing and verification. Implemented in crates.io infrastructure and cargo's verification process.
      • Requirement: Use HTTPS for all communication with crates.io to protect data in transit. Implemented in cargo's network communication layer.

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

flowchart LR
    subgraph Rust Ecosystem
        center["Cargo"]
    end

    Developers("Rust Developers")
    CratesIO("crates.io")
    RustLang("Rust Language Toolchain")

    Developers --> center: Uses
    center --> CratesIO: Downloads/Publishes Crates
    center --> RustLang: Part of Toolchain
    RustLang --> Developers: Provides Toolchain

    style center fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • C4 Context Elements:
      • Name: Cargo
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: The Rust package manager and build system. It is responsible for managing dependencies, building Rust projects, and packaging crates for distribution.
      • Responsibilities: Dependency resolution, build process management, crate packaging, interaction with crates.io, project configuration management.
      • Security controls: Input validation, secure communication with crates.io, verification of crate integrity, secure build process (inherent in Rust and cargo design).
      • Name: Rust Developers
      • Type: Person
      • Description: Users of Cargo to build, manage, and publish Rust projects and libraries.
      • Responsibilities: Writing Rust code, defining project dependencies in Cargo.toml, using cargo commands to build and manage projects, publishing crates to crates.io.
      • Security controls: Securely managing their own development environments and credentials for crates.io.
      • Name: crates.io
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: The official package registry for Rust crates. It stores and serves Rust packages to the community.
      • Responsibilities: Hosting and distributing Rust crates, managing crate metadata, user authentication and authorization for publishing, ensuring crate integrity and availability.
      • Security controls: Authentication and authorization mechanisms, crate checksums and signatures, infrastructure security, vulnerability scanning.
      • Name: Rust Language Toolchain
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: The complete set of tools for developing in Rust, including the Rust compiler (rustc), standard library, and Cargo.
      • Responsibilities: Providing the core components for Rust development, including Cargo as the build and package management tool.
      • Security controls: Security of the toolchain build and release process, ensuring the integrity of distributed binaries.

C4 CONTAINER

flowchart LR
    subgraph Cargo System
        CargoCLI("Cargo CLI")
        DependencyResolver("Dependency Resolver")
        BuildSystem("Build System")
        PackageManager("Package Manager")
        ConfigManager("Configuration Manager")
    end

    CargoCLI --> ConfigManager: Reads Configuration
    CargoCLI --> DependencyResolver: Invokes Resolution
    CargoCLI --> BuildSystem: Invokes Build
    CargoCLI --> PackageManager: Invokes Package Management
    DependencyResolver --> CratesIO: Fetches Crate Information
    BuildSystem --> RustCompiler("Rust Compiler (rustc)") : Invokes Compilation
    PackageManager --> CratesIO: Publishes/Downloads Crates

    style CargoCLI fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style DependencyResolver fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style BuildSystem fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style PackageManager fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style ConfigManager fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • C4 Container Elements:
      • Name: Cargo CLI
      • Type: Application
      • Description: Command-line interface for interacting with Cargo. It parses user commands, orchestrates other Cargo components, and presents output to the user.
      • Responsibilities: Command parsing, user interaction, invoking other Cargo components, displaying results.
      • Security controls: Input validation of command-line arguments, secure handling of user input.
      • Name: Dependency Resolver
      • Type: Application Component
      • Description: Responsible for resolving project dependencies based on Cargo.toml and interacting with crates.io to fetch crate information.
      • Responsibilities: Parsing Cargo.toml, resolving dependency graphs, fetching crate metadata from crates.io, handling version constraints.
      • Security controls: Input validation of Cargo.toml and crate metadata, secure communication with crates.io, handling potential dependency conflicts securely.
      • Name: Build System
      • Type: Application Component
      • Description: Manages the build process of Rust projects, including compiling code, linking libraries, and running tests. It interacts with the Rust compiler (rustc).
      • Responsibilities: Compiling Rust code, managing build scripts, running tests, linking libraries, handling build profiles.
      • Security controls: Secure invocation of rustc, handling build script execution securely, preventing command injection vulnerabilities in build process.
      • Name: Package Manager
      • Type: Application Component
      • Description: Handles packaging and distribution of Rust crates, including publishing to and downloading from crates.io.
      • Responsibilities: Packaging crates, interacting with crates.io for publishing and downloading, managing local crate cache.
      • Security controls: Secure communication with crates.io, verification of downloaded crate integrity, secure handling of publishing credentials.
      • Name: Configuration Manager
      • Type: Application Component
      • Description: Manages Cargo's configuration, including reading Cargo.toml files and handling environment variables and command-line options.
      • Responsibilities: Parsing Cargo.toml, managing configuration settings, providing configuration data to other Cargo components.
      • Security controls: Input validation of Cargo.toml, secure handling of configuration data, preventing configuration injection vulnerabilities.

DEPLOYMENT

  • Deployment Architecture Options:

    • Option 1: Distribute Cargo as part of the Rust toolchain installers (recommended and primary method).
    • Option 2: Distribute Cargo binaries through operating system package managers (e.g., apt, yum, brew).
    • Option 3: Allow users to build Cargo from source.

  • Detailed Deployment Architecture (Option 1 - Rust Toolchain Installer):

flowchart LR
    subgraph Rust Build Infrastructure
        RustCompilerBuild("Rust Compiler Build System")
        CargoBuild("Cargo Build System")
        InstallerBuild("Installer Build System")
        ReleaseInfra("Release Infrastructure")
    end

    DeveloperWorkstation("Developer Workstation")
    DistributionNetwork("Distribution Network (CDN)")
    UserWorkstation("User Workstation")

    DeveloperWorkstation --> RustCompilerBuild: Code Changes
    RustCompilerBuild --> CargoBuild: Builds Cargo
    CargoBuild --> InstallerBuild: Includes Cargo in Installer
    InstallerBuild --> ReleaseInfra: Publishes Installer
    ReleaseInfra --> DistributionNetwork: Distributes Installer
    DistributionNetwork --> UserWorkstation: Downloads Installer
    UserWorkstation --> CargoCLI: Executes Cargo

    style RustCompilerBuild fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style CargoBuild fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style InstallerBuild fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style ReleaseInfra fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style CargoCLI fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • Deployment Elements (Option 1 - Rust Toolchain Installer):
      • Name: Rust Build Infrastructure
      • Type: Infrastructure
      • Description: The infrastructure used by the Rust project to build the Rust toolchain, including Cargo, and create installers.
      • Responsibilities: Building the Rust compiler, Cargo, and other tools, creating installers for different platforms, managing release processes.
      • Security controls: Secure build environment, access control to build systems, code signing of releases, infrastructure security.
      • Name: Developer Workstation
      • Type: Infrastructure
      • Description: Workstations used by Rust developers to contribute code changes to the Rust project, including Cargo.
      • Responsibilities: Code development, testing, contributing to the Rust project.
      • Security controls: Secure development practices, access control, endpoint security.
      • Name: Distribution Network (CDN)
      • Type: Infrastructure
      • Description: Content Delivery Network used to distribute Rust toolchain installers to users globally.
      • Responsibilities: Hosting and distributing installer files, ensuring fast and reliable downloads.
      • Security controls: CDN security features, protection against DDoS attacks, integrity of distributed files.
      • Name: User Workstation
      • Type: Infrastructure
      • Description: End-user machines where Rust developers install the Rust toolchain, including Cargo, to develop Rust applications.
      • Responsibilities: Running Cargo to build and manage Rust projects.
      • Security controls: User workstation security practices, operating system security, endpoint security.
      • Name: Cargo CLI
      • Type: Software
      • Description: The Cargo command-line interface, deployed as part of the Rust toolchain on user workstations.
      • Responsibilities: Providing Cargo functionality to users on their local machines.
      • Security controls: Inherits security controls from the Rust toolchain deployment and user workstation security.

BUILD

flowchart LR
    Developer("Rust Developer")
    GitHubRepo("GitHub Repository (rust-lang/cargo)")
    GitHubActions("GitHub Actions CI")
    RustBuildToolchain("Rust Build Toolchain")
    SecurityScanners("Security Scanners (SAST, Dependency)")
    BuildArtifacts("Build Artifacts (Binaries, Packages)")
    ReleaseInfrastructure("Release Infrastructure")

    Developer --> GitHubRepo: Code Commit/Push
    GitHubRepo --> GitHubActions: Triggers CI Workflow
    GitHubActions --> RustBuildToolchain: Builds Cargo
    GitHubActions --> SecurityScanners: Runs Security Checks
    RustBuildToolchain --> BuildArtifacts: Creates Binaries
    SecurityScanners --> BuildArtifacts: Security Scan Results
    BuildArtifacts --> ReleaseInfrastructure: Publishes Artifacts

    style GitHubActions fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style SecurityScanners fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
Loading
  • Build Process Elements:
      • Name: Rust Developer
      • Type: Person
      • Description: Developers contributing to the Cargo project.
      • Responsibilities: Writing code, submitting pull requests, code reviews.
      • Security controls: Secure development practices, code review process.
      • Name: GitHub Repository (rust-lang/cargo)
      • Type: Code Repository
      • Description: The source code repository for Cargo hosted on GitHub.
      • Responsibilities: Version control, code storage, collaboration platform.
      • Security controls: GitHub's security features, access control, branch protection.
      • Name: GitHub Actions CI
      • Type: CI/CD System
      • Description: GitHub Actions workflows used for continuous integration and build automation for Cargo.
      • Responsibilities: Automated building, testing, and security checks of Cargo code on every commit and pull request.
      • Security controls: Secure CI/CD pipeline configuration, access control to workflows and secrets, isolation of build environments.
      • Name: Rust Build Toolchain
      • Type: Build Toolchain
      • Description: The Rust toolchain used to compile and build Cargo itself.
      • Responsibilities: Compiling Rust code, linking libraries, creating Cargo binaries.
      • Security controls: Security of the Rust build toolchain, ensuring no vulnerabilities are introduced during the build process.
      • Name: Security Scanners (SAST, Dependency)
      • Type: Security Tool
      • Description: Static analysis security testing (SAST) tools and dependency scanners integrated into the CI pipeline to automatically detect potential vulnerabilities.
      • Responsibilities: Identifying potential security flaws in the code and dependencies.
      • Security controls: Configuration and maintenance of security scanning tools, integration with CI pipeline, vulnerability reporting.
      • Name: Build Artifacts (Binaries, Packages)
      • Type: Software Artifacts
      • Description: The compiled binaries and packages of Cargo produced by the build process.
      • Responsibilities: Storing and managing build artifacts, ensuring their integrity.
      • Security controls: Integrity checks of build artifacts, secure storage of artifacts.
      • Name: Release Infrastructure
      • Type: Release System
      • Description: Infrastructure used to publish and distribute Cargo releases as part of the Rust toolchain.
      • Responsibilities: Publishing releases, managing release channels, distributing installers.
      • Security controls: Secure release process, code signing, access control to release infrastructure.

RISK ASSESSMENT

  • Critical Business Processes:

    • Building Rust projects: Cargo is essential for compiling and linking Rust code, which is the core process for any Rust development.
    • Dependency management: Cargo manages project dependencies, ensuring correct versions are downloaded and used, crucial for project stability and reproducibility.
    • Crate publishing and distribution: Cargo enables the Rust ecosystem by allowing developers to publish and share libraries (crates) through crates.io.

  • Data to Protect and Sensitivity:

    • Source code of Cargo: High sensitivity. Compromise could lead to vulnerabilities in Cargo itself, affecting the entire Rust ecosystem.
    • Build artifacts of Cargo: High sensitivity. Compromised binaries could be distributed to users, leading to widespread impact.
    • Crates.io API keys and publishing credentials: High sensitivity. Compromise could allow unauthorized publishing of malicious crates.
    • Metadata of crates on crates.io: Medium sensitivity. Integrity of crate metadata is important for dependency resolution and security.
    • User configuration (Cargo.toml, .cargo config): Low to Medium sensitivity. May contain project-specific settings and potentially internal repository URLs.

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

  • Questions:

    • What specific SAST and dependency scanning tools are currently used in the Cargo CI pipeline?
    • Is there a formal security incident response plan for Cargo and crates.io?
    • Are there regular penetration tests or security audits conducted for Cargo and crates.io?
    • What is the process for handling and disclosing vulnerabilities found in Cargo or crates.io?
    • Are there specific security training programs for Cargo developers?

  • Assumptions:

    • Cargo development follows secure coding practices.
    • The Rust project has a security-conscious culture.
    • Crates.io infrastructure is managed with security in mind.
    • The Rust community actively participates in security vulnerability reporting and mitigation.
    • The primary deployment method for Cargo is through the official Rust toolchain installers.