Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
206 lines (172 loc) · 13.5 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

206 lines (172 loc) · 13.5 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for timberio/vector

Mitigation Strategy: Strict Input Validation and Sanitization (using Vector Transforms)

  • Description:

    1. Define Expected Schemas: For each data source feeding into Vector, define the precise expected data format (data types, allowed values, regular expressions, maximum lengths).
    2. Implement parse_* Transforms: Use Vector's parse_* transforms (parse_syslog, parse_json, parse_regex, parse_grok, etc.) immediately after the source in the pipeline. Configure these transforms to strictly enforce the defined schemas. Example: 
      [sources.my_http_source]
  type = "http"
  # ... other source config ...

[transforms.parse_json_data]
  inputs = ["my_http_source"]
  type = "parse_json"
  field = "message" # Assuming the JSON is in a field named "message"
  drop_invalid = true  # CRUCIAL: Drop data that doesn't match the schema

[sinks.my_output]
  inputs = ["parse_json_data"]
  # ... rest of sink config ...
    3. Reject Non-Conforming Data: Ensure drop_invalid = true (or equivalent) is set on the parsing transforms. Alternatively, route invalid data to a dedicated error-handling pipeline (using route transform). Never attempt to "fix" invalid data within Vector.
    4. Length Limits (within Transforms): Use the limit transform after parsing to enforce maximum lengths for specific fields. This is a second layer of defense. 
      [transforms.limit_field_length]
  inputs = ["parse_json_data"] # After parsing
  type = "limit"
  field = "username"
  max_bytes = 64 # Example limit
  drop = true
    5. Whitelist Characters (using regex): Within parse_regex or a separate remap transform using VRL, define whitelists of allowed characters for sensitive fields using regular expressions.
    6. Rate Limiting (using throttle): Implement rate limiting within Vector using the throttle transform. This is in addition to any external rate limiting. 
      [transforms.throttle_input]
  inputs = ["my_http_source"] # Or after parsing, depending on needs
  type = "throttle"
  condition = ".timestamp > now() - duration(\"1s\")" # Example: 1 event per second
  max_events = 1
  key_fields = ["source_ip"] # Throttle based on source IP

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Injection Attacks (High Severity): Prevents malicious code/data injection by strictly enforcing input formats.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) (High Severity): Limits the impact of large inputs and high data volumes.
    • Data Corruption (Medium Severity): Ensures only valid data is processed.
    • Logic Errors (Medium Severity): Reduces errors caused by unexpected input.

  • Impact:

    • Injection Attacks: Risk significantly reduced (High to Low/Negligible).
    • Denial of Service: Risk significantly reduced (High to Medium/Low).
    • Data Corruption: Risk significantly reduced (Medium to Low).
    • Logic Errors: Risk reduced (Medium to Low).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Likely partially implemented. Parsing transforms are common, but strictness and drop_invalid are often missing. limit and throttle are less consistently used.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Comprehensive Schema Definitions: Schemas are often incomplete.
    • drop_invalid = true: This crucial setting is frequently omitted.
    • Whitelist Character Enforcement: Often overlooked.
    • Consistent throttle Usage: Rate limiting within Vector is often missing.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Transformation Logic (using VRL and Lua Sandboxing)

  • Description:

    1. Prefer VRL: Use Vector Remap Language (VRL) for transformations whenever possible. VRL is inherently safer than Lua.
    2. Lua Sandboxing (if used): If Lua is absolutely necessary:
      • Review Vector's Lua Documentation: Understand the limitations of Vector's Lua sandboxing.
      • Restrict Libraries: In the lua transform configuration, explicitly list only the required Lua libraries. Do not allow access to unnecessary libraries.
      • Disable System Calls: Ensure the Lua script cannot make system calls. Vector's sandboxing should prevent this by default, but verify.
      • Resource Limits (within Lua): If possible, set resource limits (CPU, memory) within the Lua script itself using Lua's debugging and resource control features. This is an advanced technique.
    3. Input Validation (within Transforms): Even within VRL or Lua transforms, continue to validate and sanitize data. Do not assume data is safe. Use VRL's type checking and string manipulation functions.
    4. Avoid Dynamic Code Generation: Never generate VRL or Lua code dynamically based on untrusted input within a transform. This is a critical security risk.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Remote Code Execution (RCE) (Critical Severity): Prevents arbitrary code execution through Lua vulnerabilities.
    • Data Leakage (High Severity): Reduces data leaks through transform logic errors.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) (High Severity): Limits resource consumption by malicious Lua scripts.
    • Logic Errors (Medium Severity): Input validation within transforms prevents errors.

  • Impact:

    • Remote Code Execution: Risk significantly reduced (Critical to Low/Negligible).
    • Data Leakage: Risk significantly reduced (High to Medium/Low).
    • Denial of Service: Risk reduced (High to Medium/Low).
    • Logic Errors: Risk reduced (Medium to Low).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • VRL is increasingly used. Lua sandboxing is usually enabled by default, but library restrictions and resource limits within Lua are often not explicitly configured.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Strict Lua Library Restrictions: Often, all standard Lua libraries are accessible.
    • Resource Limits within Lua: This advanced technique is rarely implemented.
    • Input Validation within Transforms: Frequently overlooked.
    • Avoidance of Dynamic Code Generation: This critical rule may be violated.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Output Handling (Sink Configuration)

  • Description:

    1. TLS/SSL Encryption: In the vector.toml configuration for each sink, ensure TLS/SSL encryption is enabled and configured correctly. Use the tls options provided by the specific sink. Example (for an HTTP sink): 
      [sinks.my_http_sink]
  type = "http"
  # ... other sink config ...
  inputs = ["..."]
  endpoint = "https://my-api.example.com" # Use HTTPS
  tls.verify_certificate = true # CRUCIAL: Verify the certificate
  tls.verify_hostname = true # CRUCIAL: Verify the hostname
    2. Authentication: Configure strong authentication for each sink using the sink's specific options. Use environment variables or a secret management system to store credentials (as described earlier, but this is configured within the sink definition).
    3. Output Validation (using remap): In high-security scenarios, add a remap transform before the sink to perform a final validation of the data being sent. This is less common but can be a valuable defense-in-depth measure. This could involve checking for data anomalies or known malicious patterns using VRL.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Breach (Critical Severity): Prevents unauthorized access to data in sinks.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks (High Severity): TLS/SSL with certificate verification protects data in transit.
    • Unauthorized Access (High Severity): Strong authentication prevents unauthorized access to sinks.
    • Data Tampering (High Severity): Output validation (if implemented) helps prevent data tampering.

  • Impact:

    • Data Breach: Risk significantly reduced (Critical to Low/Negligible).
    • Man-in-the-Middle Attacks: Risk significantly reduced (High to Low/Negligible).
    • Unauthorized Access: Risk significantly reduced (High to Low/Negligible).
    • Data Tampering: Risk reduced (High to Medium/Low).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • TLS/SSL is commonly used, but verify_certificate and verify_hostname are sometimes overlooked. Authentication is usually implemented, but credential management practices vary.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • tls.verify_certificate = true and tls.verify_hostname = true: These crucial TLS settings are often missed.
    • Output Validation (using remap): Rarely implemented.

Mitigation Strategy: Monitoring and Alerting (using internal_metrics)

  • Description:

    1. Enable internal_metrics Source: Add the internal_metrics source to your vector.toml: 
      [sources.internal_metrics]
  type = "internal_metrics"
    2. Configure a Sink for Metrics: Configure a sink (e.g., Prometheus, Datadog, InfluxDB, or even a simple file sink for testing) to receive the metrics from the internal_metrics source.
    3. Alerting (External): Set up alerts in your monitoring system (not directly within Vector) based on key Vector metrics. Examples:
      • High events_failed_total.
      • High buffer_usage_ratio.
      • Low events_processed_total.
      • High component_errors_total for specific components.
    4. Enable and Configure Vector Logging: Use the global options in vector.toml to configure logging: 
      data_dir = "/var/lib/vector"  # Ensure Vector has write access to this directory

[log]
  level = "info"  # Or "debug" for more detail, but be mindful of disk space
  format = "json" # Structured logging is recommended

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Undetected Attacks (High Severity): Metrics and logs help detect attacks.
    • Performance Degradation (Medium Severity): Metrics identify bottlenecks.
    • Configuration Errors (Medium Severity): Metrics and logs can reveal errors.
    • Data Loss (High Severity): Monitoring buffer usage helps prevent data loss.

  • Impact:

    • Undetected Attacks: Risk significantly reduced (High to Medium/Low).
    • Performance Degradation: Risk reduced (Medium to Low).
    • Configuration Errors: Risk reduced (Medium to Low).
    • Data Loss: Risk reduced (High to Medium/Low).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • internal_metrics is often not enabled by default. Basic logging is usually enabled, but the level and format may not be optimal for security monitoring.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • internal_metrics Source and Sink: This is the most significant gap.
    • Structured Logging (format = "json"): Often overlooked, making log analysis more difficult.
    • Appropriate Log Level: The log level may be too low (not enough detail) or too high (excessive disk usage).

Mitigation Strategy: Resource Limits (using Vector's Built-in Features)

  • Description:

    1. buffer Configuration (Sinks): For sinks that use buffers (e.g., file, http, kafka, clickhouse), configure the buffer settings within the sink definition in vector.toml. Set appropriate max_size and type values to control memory usage. Example: 
      [sinks.my_buffered_sink]
  type = "file" # Example
  # ... other sink config ...
  inputs = ["..."]
  path = "/path/to/output.log"
  buffer.type = "disk" # Or "memory"
  buffer.max_size = 102400 # 100KB, adjust as needed
    2. batch Configuration (Sinks): For sinks, configure batch settings (e.g., batch.max_bytes, batch.timeout_secs) to control the size and frequency of data sent to the sink. This helps prevent overwhelming the sink and can indirectly limit resource usage.
    3. throttle Transform: (Already covered in Input Validation, but it's also a resource limiting strategy). Use the throttle transform to limit the rate of data flow.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) (High Severity): Prevents Vector from being overwhelmed.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Medium Severity): Controls Vector's resource consumption.

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service: Risk significantly reduced (High to Medium/Low).
    • Resource Exhaustion: Risk significantly reduced (Medium to Low).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • buffer settings are sometimes configured, but often not optimized. batch settings are commonly used. throttle is less consistently used for resource limiting.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Optimized buffer Settings: The max_size may be too large or not set at all.
    • Strategic Use of throttle: throttle is often not used proactively to limit resource usage.