Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
84 lines (65 loc) · 11 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

84 lines (65 loc) · 11 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for herotransitions/hero

Mitigation Strategy: Minimize Sensitive Data in Transitioning Views

  • Mitigation Strategy: Minimize Sensitive Data in Transitioning Views

  • Description:

    1. Identify Hero Transitions with Sensitive Views: Review all screens where Hero transitions are implemented and identify views within those transitions that display sensitive information (e.g., passwords, credit card details, personal identification numbers, API keys, etc.).
    2. Implement Placeholder Logic for Hero Transitions: When initiating a Hero transition involving sensitive views, programmatically replace the actual sensitive data in those views with non-sensitive placeholders (e.g., asterisks, masked values, generic icons) before the Hero transition animation starts. This ensures the sensitive data is not rendered during the transition animation managed by Hero.
    3. Restore Sensitive Data Post-Hero Transition: After the Hero transition animation completes and the destination screen is fully visible and interactive, restore the actual sensitive data in the view. This should be done programmatically in the destination Activity/Fragment, ensuring the sensitive data is only revealed after the Hero transition is finished.
    4. Verify Placeholder Behavior in Hero Transitions: Thoroughly test all Hero transitions involving sensitive views to confirm that placeholders are correctly displayed throughout the Hero transition animation and that sensitive data is only revealed after the transition is complete.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Exposure during Hero Transitions (High Severity): Reduces the risk of sensitive data being visually exposed during screen transitions animated by Hero, especially if someone is observing the screen or if screen recording is active.
    • Data Logging in Custom Hero Transitions (Medium Severity): Minimizes the chance of sensitive data being inadvertently logged by custom Hero transition code or logging frameworks if placeholders are used during the Hero transition phase.

  • Impact:

    • Data Exposure during Hero Transitions: Significantly reduces the risk. Sensitive data is not directly rendered in views undergoing Hero transitions, protecting it during the vulnerable animation period.
    • Data Logging in Custom Hero Transitions: Moderately reduces the risk. If logging is accidentally enabled, placeholders instead of real data will be logged during Hero transitions.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Unknown/Not Applicable: This mitigation is application-specific and needs to be implemented within the application's codebase wherever Hero transitions are used with sensitive data. It is not a feature of the Hero library itself.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Likely Missing in Most Projects: This is a proactive security measure often overlooked unless specifically considering data exposure during UI transitions, especially those powered by libraries like Hero. It's likely missing in projects that haven't explicitly addressed sensitive data handling in the context of Hero transitions. Check Activities/Fragments using Hero transitions and displaying sensitive data.

Mitigation Strategy: Review Custom Hero Transition Implementations for Logging

  • Mitigation Strategy: Review Custom Hero Transition Implementations for Logging

  • Description:

    1. Identify Custom Hero Transitions: Locate all custom hero transition implementations within the project. This specifically includes classes extending HeroModifier or any custom transition logic directly integrated with Hero within Activities/Fragments.
    2. Code Review of Hero Transition Logic for Logging: Carefully review the code of each custom Hero transition implementation. Focus on the code that is directly manipulating views or data as part of the Hero transition animation. Look for any logging statements (e.g., Log.d(), Log.e(), custom logging frameworks) within this Hero-specific transition code.
    3. Examine Logged Data in Hero Transitions: If logging statements are found within custom Hero transition code, analyze what data is being logged during the transition process. Pay close attention to whether any sensitive data (user inputs, API responses, internal application state) is being logged as part of the Hero transition.
    4. Remove or Secure Logging in Hero Transitions:
      • Remove Unnecessary Hero Transition Logging: Delete any logging statements within custom Hero transition code that are not essential for debugging or monitoring in development environments.
      • Conditional Hero Transition Logging: Wrap necessary logging statements within custom Hero transition code in conditional blocks that are only active in debug builds (e.g., using BuildConfig.DEBUG). Ensure logging is disabled or minimized in release builds, especially within Hero transition logic.
      • Secure Logging Practices for Hero Transitions (Discouraged): If logging sensitive data is deemed absolutely necessary for debugging Hero transitions (highly discouraged in production), implement secure logging practices like data masking or encryption before logging within the Hero transition code.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Logging in Custom Hero Transitions (Medium Severity): Directly mitigates the risk of sensitive data being logged during custom Hero transitions, which could be exposed through logcat, crash reports, or logging aggregation systems.

  • Impact:

    • Data Logging in Custom Hero Transitions: Significantly reduces the risk. By removing or securing logging within custom Hero transition code, the chance of unintentional data exposure through logs generated during transitions is minimized.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Partially Implemented (Standard Best Practice): Good development practices generally encourage minimal logging in production builds. However, specific review for logging within custom Hero transition code might be missing.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Specific Hero Transition Logging Review: While general logging practices might be in place, a dedicated review focusing specifically on logging within custom Hero transition code is likely missing. Developers might not explicitly consider the transition phase, especially when using a library like Hero, as a potential logging vulnerability point. This review should be conducted across all custom Hero transition implementations.

Mitigation Strategy: Thoroughly Test Hero Transition Flows

  • Mitigation Strategy: Thoroughly Test Hero Transition Flows

  • Description:

    1. Create Hero Transition Specific Test Cases: Develop a comprehensive set of test cases specifically designed to cover all Hero transition scenarios within the application. Include:
      • Transitions between different Activities and Fragments using Hero.
      • Transitions triggered by various user actions that initiate Hero animations (button clicks, list item selections, gestures).
      • Hero transitions with different data sets and UI states involved in the animation.
      • Hero transitions under different device conditions (low memory, slow network, etc.) to assess performance and stability.
      • Edge cases and error scenarios that might occur during Hero transitions.
    2. Manual Testing of Hero Transitions on Diverse Devices: Perform manual testing of all Hero transition test cases on a variety of Android devices with different screen sizes, resolutions, and Android versions. Specifically focus on:
      • Visual correctness of Hero transitions (animations, view positioning, layering as managed by Hero).
      • UI element interactivity during Hero transitions (ensure only intended elements are interactive at each stage of the Hero animation).
      • Performance and smoothness of Hero transitions, especially on lower-end devices.
      • Absence of unexpected UI behavior or glitches related to Hero transitions.
    3. Automated UI Testing for Hero Transitions (Espresso, UI Automator): Implement automated UI tests using frameworks like Espresso or UI Automator to cover key Hero transition flows. Automate tests to:
      • Verify UI element states before, during, and after Hero transitions.
      • Check for unexpected exceptions or crashes specifically during Hero transitions.
      • Ensure UI elements are interactable at the correct times throughout Hero animations.
    4. Usability Testing Focused on Hero Transitions: Conduct usability testing with real users to observe how they interact with Hero transitions and identify any potential usability issues or unexpected behaviors caused by or related to the Hero animations that could indirectly lead to security concerns (e.g., accidental clicks due to confusing UI states during Hero transitions).

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Unintended UI Interactions and Clickjacking due to Hero Transitions (Indirect, Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of users unintentionally interacting with UI elements during Hero transitions due to unexpected behavior or confusing UI states created by the animations.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) or Performance Issues from Hero Transitions (Indirect Security Impact, Low Severity): Helps identify and address performance bottlenecks or resource-intensive Hero transitions that could lead to performance degradation or DoS-like conditions, especially if complex Hero animations are used excessively.

  • Impact:

    • Unintended UI Interactions and Clickjacking: Moderately reduces the risk. Thorough testing of Hero transitions helps identify and fix UI issues specifically arising from the animations that could lead to unintended interactions.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) or Performance Issues: Slightly reduces the risk. Performance testing of Hero transitions helps identify and optimize resource-intensive animations.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Partially Implemented (Standard QA Practices): Projects likely have some level of testing, but specific and comprehensive testing focused on Hero transition flows might be lacking. General UI testing might not specifically target the nuances of Hero animations.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Dedicated Hero Transition Testing Strategy: A dedicated testing strategy specifically targeting Hero transitions is likely missing. This includes creating specific test cases focused on Hero animations, allocating resources for testing on diverse devices with a focus on Hero transition performance, and implementing automated UI tests specifically validating Hero transition flows. This should be integrated into the project's QA process.