Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
73 lines (54 loc) · 7.25 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

73 lines (54 loc) · 7.25 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for mengto/spring

Mitigation Strategy: Delayed Loading of Secrets (Spring-Specific Aspects)

  • Description:

    1. dotenv-rails Configuration: Ensure dotenv-rails (or your chosen environment variable management solution) is loaded after Spring forks. This is crucial. Place dotenv-rails within a group in the Gemfile that is loaded after Rails initializes (e.g., the :development, :test groups), not at the top level.
    2. Initializer Refactoring: Avoid direct use of ENV[...] within initializers (config/initializers/*.rb). If absolutely necessary, ensure the initializer is designed to re-fetch the value on each request (e.g., by wrapping the access in a method) rather than caching it at startup. This prevents Spring from holding onto stale or potentially exposed environment variables. Prefer a dedicated secrets retrieval mechanism.
    3. Secrets Manager Integration (Post-Fork): If using a secrets manager (recommended for production), ensure that secrets are fetched dynamically at runtime, after Spring has forked. This usually involves creating a helper method or class that retrieves secrets on demand, and never storing secrets in instance variables initialized at application startup.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Environment Variable Leakage (High Severity): Prevents secrets loaded before Spring forks from persisting in the Spring server process, making them vulnerable if the process is compromised.
    • Stale Secrets (Medium Severity): Ensures that changes to secrets are picked up after a spring stop and restart, without requiring a full application restart.
    • Accidental Exposure (High Severity): Reduces the risk of secrets being accidentally logged or included in error messages, as they are not readily available in the ENV.

  • Impact:

    • Environment Variable Leakage: Risk significantly reduced (from High to Low).
    • Stale Secrets: Risk reduced (from Medium to Low).
    • Accidental Exposure: Risk significantly reduced (from High to Low).

  • Currently Implemented: Partially. dotenv-rails is used, but it's loaded incorrectly in the Gemfile (top level). Secrets are accessed via ENV[...] in several initializers.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • dotenv-rails needs to be moved within a group in the Gemfile.
    • Initializers need refactoring to avoid caching ENV values. A helper method should be used.
    • A secrets manager should be considered for production, with secrets fetched after Spring forks.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Spring Restarts

  • Description:

    1. Restart Mechanism: Implement a mechanism to regularly restart the Spring server. This can be:
      • Cron Job: A scheduled task (e.g., using cron on Linux) that runs spring stop at a set interval. Example: 0 0 * * * /path/to/your/app/bin/spring stop (restarts daily at midnight).
      • Deployment Hook: Integrate spring stop into your deployment scripts to ensure Spring is restarted after each code deployment. This is essential.
      • Process Manager (with restart capabilities): If using a process manager like systemd or upstart, configure it to automatically restart Spring if it crashes or becomes unresponsive.
    2. Frequency: Determine an appropriate restart frequency. Daily restarts are a good starting point, but more frequent restarts might be necessary for highly sensitive applications.
    3. Monitoring: Monitor the restarts to ensure they are successful and that Spring comes back up correctly.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Stale Secrets (Medium Severity): Ensures that changes to secrets (especially those managed outside of dotenv-rails) are picked up by the application.
    • Memory Leaks (Low Severity): Helps to clear out any memory leaks that might have accumulated in the long-running Spring server process.
    • Zombie/Stale Processes (Low Severity): Cleans up any orphaned or unresponsive Spring processes that might be consuming resources.
    • Lingering Effects of Exploits (Medium Severity): If an exploit did manage to temporarily compromise the Spring process, regular restarts limit the duration of that compromise.

  • Impact:

    • Stale Secrets: Risk reduced (from Medium to Low).
    • Memory Leaks: Risk reduced (from Low to Very Low).
    • Zombie/Stale Processes: Risk reduced (from Low to Very Low).
    • Lingering Effects of Exploits: Risk reduced (from Medium to Low).

  • Currently Implemented: Partially. Spring is restarted after deployments, but there is no regular restart schedule (e.g., via cron).

  • Missing Implementation: A cron job (or similar mechanism) should be set up to restart Spring daily, in addition to the deployment-triggered restarts.

Mitigation Strategy: Explicit spring stop in Deployment and Critical Operations

  • Description:

    1. Deployment Scripts: Always include spring stop (or a more robust process management command that ensures Spring is completely stopped) in your deployment scripts. This should happen before any code updates or migrations are run. This prevents conflicts and ensures that the new code is loaded correctly by Spring.
    2. Database Migrations (Optional, but Recommended): Consider adding spring stop before running database migrations, and spring start (or allowing Spring to start automatically on the next command) after the migrations are complete. This can help prevent issues with schema changes and cached data in Spring. This is more important if you have complex migrations or are using features that rely heavily on schema caching.
    3. Other Critical Operations: Identify any other critical operations (e.g., major configuration changes, gem updates) that might require a Spring restart. Include spring stop in the scripts or procedures for these operations.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Stale Code/Configuration (Medium Severity): Ensures that the latest code and configuration are loaded by Spring after deployments or changes.
    • Database Migration Conflicts (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of conflicts between database migrations and Spring's cached schema information.
    • Inconsistent Application State (Low Severity): Helps to prevent the application from entering an inconsistent state due to outdated code or configuration being used by Spring.

  • Impact:

    • Stale Code/Configuration: Risk significantly reduced (from Medium to Low).
    • Database Migration Conflicts: Risk reduced (from Medium to Low).
    • Inconsistent Application State: Risk reduced (from Low to Very Low).

  • Currently Implemented: Partially. spring stop is included in deployment scripts, but not consistently before database migrations.

  • Missing Implementation: spring stop should be consistently added before database migrations, and potentially before other critical operations that could be affected by Spring's cached state.