Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
199 lines (152 loc) · 12.4 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

199 lines (152 loc) · 12.4 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for rxswiftcommunity/rxdatasources

Mitigation Strategy: Immutable Data Structures

1. Mitigation Strategy: Immutable Data Structures

  • Description:

    1. Model Definition: Define all data models used for sections and items in RxDataSources as Swift structs.
    2. Property Immutability: Declare all properties within these structs using the let keyword, making them immutable after initialization.
    3. Data Transformation: When data needs to be updated, create new instances of the struct with the updated values, rather than modifying existing instances. This is typically done within your Rx stream using operators like map.
    4. Example: 
      struct MyItem: IdentifiableType, Equatable {
    let id: UUID
    let title: String
    let description: String

    var identity: UUID { return id }

    static func == (lhs: MyItem, rhs: MyItem) -> Bool {
        return lhs.id == rhs.id && lhs.title == rhs.title && lhs.description == rhs.description
    }
}

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes (Denial of Service): (Severity: High) - Prevents accidental or malicious modification of data outside the Rx stream, eliminating a major cause of crashes and UI glitches specific to how RxDataSources interacts with data.
    • Incorrect Diffing and Data Exposure: (Severity: Medium) - Reduces the likelihood of incorrect diffing due to unexpected data changes, which is a direct consequence of RxDataSources' diffing algorithm.

  • Impact:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes: Risk significantly reduced (80-90%). The primary source of this threat within the context of RxDataSources is eliminated.
    • Incorrect Diffing: Risk moderately reduced (40-50%). Immutability helps, but correct IdentifiableType and Equatable are still crucial (see below).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Yes/No/Partially: (Specify where it's implemented - e.g., "Yes, in ProductListViewController and UserProfileViewController data models.")
    • Example: "Partially. Implemented in ProductListViewController, but OrderHistoryViewController still uses mutable models."

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Specify where it's not implemented - e.g., "Missing in OrderHistoryViewController data models. Need to refactor to use immutable structs.")
    • Example: "OrderHistoryViewController needs refactoring. Also, review all models used with RxDataSources to ensure consistency."

Mitigation Strategy: Single Source of Truth

2. Mitigation Strategy: Single Source of Truth

  • Description:

    1. Identify the Observable: Clearly define the single Observable (or BehaviorRelay, PublishRelay, etc.) that will be the source of data for your RxDataSources.
    2. Centralized Updates: All modifications to the data displayed by RxDataSources must be performed by emitting new values on this observable.
    3. No Direct Manipulation: Absolutely no direct manipulation of the underlying data array or structure after it's been passed to RxDataSources. This is critical because RxDataSources maintains internal state based on the data it receives.
    4. Example (using BehaviorRelay): 
      let itemsRelay = BehaviorRelay<[MySection]>(value: [])

// Bind to RxDataSources
itemsRelay
    .bind(to: tableView.rx.items(dataSource: dataSource))
    .disposed(by: disposeBag)

// Update data ONLY through the relay
func updateItems(newItems: [MyItem]) {
    let newSection = MySection(items: newItems)
    itemsRelay.accept([newSection]) // Emit a NEW array
}

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes (Denial of Service): (Severity: High) - Enforces controlled data updates, preventing race conditions and inconsistencies that lead to crashes specifically because of how RxDataSources manages its internal state and diffing.

  • Impact:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes: Risk significantly reduced (70-80%). Combined with immutable data structures, this provides very strong protection against RxDataSources-specific issues.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Yes/No/Partially: (Specify where it's implemented)
    • Example: "Yes, consistently enforced. All updates go through dedicated BehaviorRelay instances."

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Specify where it's not implemented)
    • Example: "Need to audit all data update paths to ensure they go through the designated observables. Pay close attention to any manual array manipulations."

Mitigation Strategy: Thread Safety (Main Thread Updates)

3. Mitigation Strategy: Thread Safety (Main Thread Updates)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Background Operations: Identify any code that updates your data source from a background thread.
    2. Observe on Main Thread: Use the observe(on: MainScheduler.instance) operator in your Rx stream to ensure that any updates to the observable that feeds into RxDataSources are performed on the main thread. This is crucial because RxDataSources interacts directly with UIKit, which must be done on the main thread.
    3. Placement: Place observe(on: MainScheduler.instance) before the bind(to:) call, but after any operations that need to happen on a background thread.
    4. Example: 
      networkRequestObservable
    .map { response in /* ... */ }
    .observe(on: MainScheduler.instance) // Switch to the main thread
    .bind(to: tableView.rx.items(dataSource: dataSource)) // Bind on the main thread
    .disposed(by: disposeBag)

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes (Denial of Service): (Severity: High) - Prevents UI updates from being attempted on background threads, which is a direct violation of UIKit rules and can lead to crashes when using RxDataSources (or any UI binding).

  • Impact:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes: Risk significantly reduced (60-70%) for issues specifically related to threading and RxDataSources' interaction with UIKit.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Yes/No/Partially: (Specify where it's implemented)
    • Example: "Partially. Implemented for network requests, but need to check data processing from local storage."

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Specify where it's not implemented)
    • Example: "Audit all data sources feeding into RxDataSources. Any operation that might be on a background thread needs observe(on: MainScheduler.instance) before binding."

Mitigation Strategy: Correct IdentifiableType and Equatable

4. Mitigation Strategy: Correct IdentifiableType and Equatable

  • Description:

    1. IdentifiableType:
      • Ensure your data models conform to IdentifiableType.
      • The identity property must return a unique identifier for each item. A UUID is generally recommended.
      • Do not use array indices or other volatile values. This is critical for RxDataSources' diffing algorithm.
    2. Equatable:
      • Ensure your data models conform to Equatable (implement the == operator).
      • The == operator should compare all relevant properties.
      • Be consistent: If two items have the same identity, they should also be equal according to ==.
      • Avoid expensive operations within == as this directly impacts RxDataSources' performance.
    3. Testing: Write unit tests specifically to verify the correctness of both IdentifiableType and Equatable implementations. This is essential for RxDataSources.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Incorrect Diffing and Data Exposure: (Severity: Medium) - Ensures that RxDataSources correctly identifies changes in the data, preventing incorrect animations and potential data leaks. This is entirely dependent on these implementations being correct.

  • Impact:

    • Incorrect Diffing: Risk significantly reduced (70-80%). Correct implementations are essential for RxDataSources' core functionality.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Yes/No/Partially: (Specify where it's implemented)
    • Example: "Yes, implemented. Unit tests exist for Product and User models."

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Specify where it's not implemented)
    • Example: "Add unit tests for all new data models as they are created. Review existing tests for completeness, specifically targeting RxDataSources' diffing behavior."

Mitigation Strategy: Robust Error Handling (Within Rx Streams)

5. Mitigation Strategy: Robust Error Handling (Within Rx Streams)

  • Description:

    1. catchError / catchErrorJustReturn: Within your Rx streams that feed into RxDataSources, use catchError or catchErrorJustReturn to handle any errors.
    2. Logging: Log any errors that are caught.
    3. User Feedback: Provide appropriate feedback to the user.
    4. Example: 
      networkRequestObservable
    .map { response in /* ... */ }
    .catchError { error in
        print("Network error: \(error)") // Log
        return .just([]) // Return empty array for RxDataSources
    }
    .observe(on: MainScheduler.instance)
    .bind(to: tableView.rx.items(dataSource: dataSource))
    .disposed(by: disposeBag)

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes (Denial of Service): (Severity: Medium) - Prevents unexpected errors within the Rx stream from crashing the application when using RxDataSources.

  • Impact:

    • Data Inconsistency and Crashes: Risk moderately reduced (30-40%). Error handling prevents crashes related to the Rx stream feeding RxDataSources.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Yes/No/Partially: (Specify where it's implemented)
    • Example: "Partially. catchError used in some places, but needs more consistent logging and user feedback, especially in streams bound to RxDataSources."

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Specify where it's not implemented)
    • Example: "Implement a centralized error handling and logging strategy for all Rx streams, paying particular attention to those directly connected to RxDataSources."

Mitigation Strategy: Dispose Bags and Subscription Management

6. Mitigation Strategy: Dispose Bags and Subscription Management

  • Description:

    1. DisposeBag: Create a DisposeBag instance in each view controller (or other object) that manages Rx subscriptions, especially those related to RxDataSources.
    2. Add to Bag: Add every subscription created using bind(to:) (with RxDataSources), subscribe(onNext:), etc., to the DisposeBag using .disposed(by: disposeBag).
    3. Deallocation: Ensure the DisposeBag is deallocated when the owning object is deallocated.
    4. take(until:) (Optional): Consider using take(until:) for subscriptions that should terminate based on a specific event.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Memory Leaks: (Severity: Medium) - Prevents subscriptions related to RxDataSources from keeping objects alive in memory.

  • Impact:

    • Memory Leaks: Risk significantly reduced (90-100%) if implemented correctly, preventing leaks specifically caused by RxDataSources bindings.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Yes/No/Partially: (Specify where it's implemented)
    • Example: "Yes, consistently used. Each view controller using RxDataSources has its own DisposeBag."

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Specify where it's not implemented)
    • Example: "Regularly profile the application for memory leaks using Instruments to catch any missed cases, particularly focusing on view controllers using RxDataSources."