Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
271 lines (196 loc) · 30 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

271 lines (196 loc) · 30 KB

Deep Security Analysis of Duende IdentityServer

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective:

The objective of this deep security analysis is to thoroughly evaluate the security design of Duende IdentityServer, as outlined in the provided design review document, to identify potential security vulnerabilities, weaknesses, and areas for improvement. This analysis will focus on understanding the architecture, components, and data flow of Duende IdentityServer to provide specific and actionable security recommendations tailored to the product. The ultimate goal is to enhance the security posture of applications utilizing Duende IdentityServer by addressing potential threats and implementing robust mitigation strategies.

Scope:

This analysis will cover the following aspects of Duende IdentityServer, based on the design review document:

  • Core Components: IdentityServer Core, User Store, Configuration Store, Token Store, Operational Store.
  • Optional Components: Admin UI, External Identity Providers, Operational Monitoring.
  • Data Flow: Authorization Code Flow with PKCE and other mentioned OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect flows.
  • Technology Stack: ASP.NET Core, C#, database support, caching, logging, and deployment environments.
  • Security Considerations: Configuration Security, Authentication Security, Authorization Security, Token Security, and Operational Security as detailed in section 8 of the design review.
  • Deployment Architecture: Single instance, load-balanced, clustered, containerized, and cloud-native deployments.

The analysis will not include:

  • Source code review: Direct examination of the Duende IdentityServer codebase is outside the scope. The analysis will be based on the design document and inferred architecture.
  • Penetration testing: No active security testing will be performed.
  • Third-party component analysis in detail: While integrations are considered, deep dives into the security of specific databases, caching systems, or external identity providers are excluded.
  • Compliance audits: This is not a formal compliance audit against specific standards (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA).

Methodology:

This deep security analysis will employ the following methodology:

  1. Document Review: A thorough review of the provided "Project Design Document: Duende IdentityServer" to understand the system's architecture, components, data flow, and stated security considerations.
  2. Architecture and Data Flow Inference: Based on the document, infer the detailed architecture, component interactions, and data flow paths for various authentication and authorization scenarios.
  3. Threat Modeling (Implicit): While not explicitly creating formal threat models, the analysis will implicitly perform threat modeling by considering potential threats relevant to each component and data flow based on common security vulnerabilities in identity and access management systems and web applications.
  4. Security Implication Breakdown: For each key component and data flow, analyze the security implications, focusing on potential vulnerabilities and weaknesses.
  5. Specific Recommendation Generation: Develop specific and actionable security recommendations tailored to Duende IdentityServer and its components, addressing the identified security implications.
  6. Mitigation Strategy Formulation: For each recommendation, formulate practical and tailored mitigation strategies that can be implemented to enhance the security posture of Duende IdentityServer deployments.
  7. Documentation and Reporting: Document the analysis process, findings, recommendations, and mitigation strategies in a clear and structured report.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

2.1. IdentityServer Core

Security Implications:

  • Central Point of Failure: As the core engine, vulnerabilities in IdentityServer Core can have widespread impact, affecting all applications relying on it for authentication and authorization.
  • Protocol Implementation Flaws: Bugs or misconfigurations in the implementation of OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect protocols within the core could lead to bypasses, information disclosure, or unauthorized access.
  • Token Handling Vulnerabilities: Improper token issuance, validation, or revocation logic can result in token theft, replay attacks, or privilege escalation.
  • Session Management Weaknesses: Vulnerabilities in session management could lead to session hijacking or fixation attacks.
  • Extensibility Point Abuse: Security flaws in extensibility points (e.g., custom event handlers, user store integrations) could be exploited to compromise the system.
  • Denial of Service (DoS): The core component is a target for DoS attacks due to its central role in handling all authentication and authorization requests.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Rigorous Code Reviews and Security Audits: Conduct thorough code reviews and regular security audits of the IdentityServer Core codebase, focusing on protocol implementations, token handling logic, and session management.
  • Penetration Testing: Perform regular penetration testing specifically targeting IdentityServer Core to identify potential vulnerabilities in its logic and implementation.
  • Input Validation and Output Encoding: Implement strict input validation for all incoming requests and proper output encoding to prevent injection attacks and XSS vulnerabilities within the core processing logic.
  • Secure Dependency Management: Maintain a secure dependency management process, ensuring all libraries and frameworks used by IdentityServer Core are up-to-date and free from known vulnerabilities. Regularly scan dependencies for vulnerabilities.
  • Rate Limiting and DoS Protection: Implement robust rate limiting mechanisms at the IdentityServer Core level to protect against DoS attacks targeting authentication and token endpoints.
  • Error Handling and Logging: Implement secure error handling practices that avoid leaking sensitive information in error messages. Ensure comprehensive logging of security-relevant events within the core for auditing and incident response.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Establish a Secure Development Lifecycle (SDLC): Integrate security into every stage of the development lifecycle, including design, coding, testing, and deployment.
  • Automated Security Testing: Implement automated security testing tools (SAST, DAST) to continuously scan the codebase for vulnerabilities.
  • Security Training for Developers: Provide developers with regular security training on secure coding practices, common web application vulnerabilities, and OAuth 2.0/OpenID Connect security best practices.
  • Implement a Web Application Firewall (WAF): Deploy a WAF in front of IdentityServer to filter malicious traffic and protect against common web attacks.
  • Intrusion Detection/Prevention System (IDS/IPS): Implement an IDS/IPS to monitor network traffic and detect/prevent malicious activity targeting IdentityServer.

2.2. User Store

Security Implications:

  • Credential Compromise: The User Store holds sensitive user credentials. A breach of the User Store is a critical security incident, leading to widespread account compromise.
  • Weak Password Storage: Inadequate password hashing algorithms or improper salting can make user credentials vulnerable to offline attacks.
  • Injection Attacks: Vulnerabilities in the User Store integration (e.g., SQL injection in database-backed stores, LDAP injection in LDAP stores) can allow attackers to bypass authentication or gain unauthorized access.
  • Data Breaches: Insufficient access controls or vulnerabilities in the User Store database or system can lead to unauthorized data access and breaches of user profile information.
  • Account Enumeration: Vulnerabilities allowing attackers to enumerate valid usernames can facilitate brute-force attacks.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Strong Password Hashing: Mandate the use of strong, salted, one-way adaptive hashing algorithms like Argon2, bcrypt, or scrypt for storing passwords. Regularly review and update hashing algorithms as needed.
  • Secure Credential Storage Infrastructure: Ensure the underlying infrastructure hosting the User Store (database servers, LDAP servers, etc.) is hardened and secured according to best practices. Implement strong access controls and encryption at rest for sensitive data.
  • Input Sanitization and Parameterized Queries: Implement robust input sanitization and use parameterized queries or ORM frameworks to prevent injection attacks when interacting with the User Store.
  • Regular Security Audits of User Store Integration: Conduct regular security audits of the integration between IdentityServer Core and the User Store, focusing on authentication logic, data access controls, and injection vulnerability prevention.
  • Account Lockout and Rate Limiting: Implement account lockout policies after multiple failed login attempts and rate limiting on authentication endpoints to mitigate brute-force password guessing and credential stuffing attacks.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) Enforcement: Strongly encourage and, where feasible, enforce MFA for user accounts to provide an additional layer of security beyond passwords.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Database Security Hardening: Implement database security best practices, including principle of least privilege for database access, regular patching, and database activity monitoring.
  • LDAP Security Hardening (if applicable): Harden LDAP/Active Directory configurations, restrict anonymous access, and implement secure LDAP communication (LDAPS).
  • Vulnerability Scanning of User Store Infrastructure: Regularly scan the infrastructure hosting the User Store for vulnerabilities and apply necessary patches promptly.
  • Data Loss Prevention (DLP) Measures: Implement DLP measures to monitor and prevent sensitive user data from being exfiltrated from the User Store.
  • Incident Response Plan for User Store Breach: Develop a specific incident response plan to address potential breaches of the User Store, including steps for containment, eradication, recovery, and post-incident analysis.

2.3. Configuration Store

Security Implications:

  • Unauthorized Configuration Changes: If the Configuration Store is compromised, attackers could modify client configurations, resource definitions, or other settings to grant themselves unauthorized access, escalate privileges, or redirect authentication flows.
  • Configuration Data Disclosure: Exposure of configuration data could reveal sensitive information about clients, resources, secrets, and system behavior, aiding attackers in further attacks.
  • Integrity Compromise: Tampering with configuration data can disrupt the intended behavior of IdentityServer and lead to security bypasses or denial of service.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Access Control and Authorization: Implement strict access control mechanisms for the Configuration Store, ensuring only authorized administrators can modify configuration data. Utilize role-based access control (RBAC) to manage permissions.
  • Secure Storage and Encryption: Store configuration data securely, considering encryption at rest for sensitive information like client secrets and API secrets within the Configuration Store.
  • Configuration Change Auditing: Implement comprehensive auditing of all configuration changes, logging who made the change, when, and what was changed. This is crucial for accountability and incident investigation.
  • Configuration Validation and Integrity Checks: Implement validation mechanisms to ensure configuration data is consistent and valid. Consider integrity checks to detect unauthorized modifications.
  • Secure Admin UI Access (if applicable): If an Admin UI is used to manage the Configuration Store, ensure it is secured with strong authentication, authorization, and protection against common web vulnerabilities.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Principle of Least Privilege for Administration: Grant administrative access to the Configuration Store only to necessary personnel and with the minimum required privileges.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication for Administrators: Enforce MFA for administrator accounts accessing the Configuration Store or Admin UI.
  • Regular Configuration Backups: Implement regular backups of the Configuration Store to facilitate recovery in case of data loss or corruption.
  • Infrastructure Security Hardening: Secure the infrastructure hosting the Configuration Store (database servers, file systems, etc.) according to security best practices.
  • Security Monitoring of Configuration Store Access: Monitor access to the Configuration Store for suspicious activity and unauthorized attempts to modify configuration data.

2.4. Token Store

Security Implications:

  • Token Theft: If the Token Store is compromised, attackers could steal issued tokens (access tokens, refresh tokens, authorization codes) and impersonate users or gain unauthorized access to protected resources.
  • Token Replay Attacks: Stolen tokens could be replayed to gain unauthorized access if proper token validation and revocation mechanisms are not in place.
  • Data Breach of Token Data: Exposure of token data could reveal sensitive information about user sessions, granted scopes, and client applications.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Secure Token Storage Infrastructure: Ensure the infrastructure hosting the Token Store (database servers, caching systems, etc.) is hardened and secured. Implement strong access controls and encryption at rest for stored tokens.
  • Token Encryption at Rest: Encrypt tokens at rest within the Token Store to protect them from unauthorized access in case of storage compromise.
  • Token Revocation Mechanisms: Implement robust token revocation mechanisms to invalidate tokens promptly when necessary (e.g., user logout, security events, compromised tokens).
  • Token Lifetime Management: Configure appropriate token lifetimes (short-lived access tokens, longer-lived refresh tokens with appropriate security measures) to minimize the window of opportunity for token misuse if stolen.
  • Regular Security Audits of Token Store Integration: Conduct regular security audits of the integration between IdentityServer Core and the Token Store, focusing on token storage, retrieval, and revocation logic.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Choose Secure Token Store Implementation: Select a Token Store implementation that is designed for security and performance, considering options like database-backed stores with encryption or distributed caching with secure access controls.
  • Regular Security Scanning of Token Store Infrastructure: Regularly scan the infrastructure hosting the Token Store for vulnerabilities and apply necessary patches.
  • Implement Token Rotation (for Refresh Tokens): Consider implementing refresh token rotation to further limit the lifespan and potential misuse of refresh tokens.
  • Monitor Token Store Access and Activity: Monitor access to the Token Store for suspicious activity and unauthorized attempts to access or manipulate token data.
  • Incident Response Plan for Token Store Breach: Develop a specific incident response plan to address potential breaches of the Token Store, including steps for token revocation, session invalidation, and user notification if necessary.

2.5. Operational Store

Security Implications:

  • Consent Data Manipulation: Tampering with consent decisions in the Operational Store could lead to unauthorized access to user data or API resources, bypassing user consent.
  • Audit Log Manipulation: If audit logs in the Operational Store are compromised, attackers could cover their tracks and make it difficult to detect security incidents.
  • Data Breach of Operational Data: Exposure of operational data could reveal sensitive information about user activity, consent history, and system events.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Integrity Protection for Operational Data: Implement mechanisms to ensure the integrity of operational data, particularly consent decisions and audit logs. Consider digital signatures or checksums to detect tampering.
  • Access Control for Operational Store: Implement strict access control mechanisms for the Operational Store, limiting access to authorized personnel and systems.
  • Secure Storage and Encryption: Store operational data securely, considering encryption at rest for sensitive information within the Operational Store.
  • Audit Log Security: Ensure audit logs are stored securely and are tamper-proof. Consider using dedicated security information and event management (SIEM) systems for centralized and secure audit log management.
  • Regular Security Audits of Operational Store Integration: Conduct regular security audits of the integration between IdentityServer Core and the Operational Store, focusing on data integrity, access controls, and audit logging.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Write-Once Storage for Audit Logs: Consider using write-once storage for audit logs to prevent tampering and ensure their integrity.
  • Centralized Logging and Monitoring (SIEM): Integrate the Operational Store's audit logs with a centralized SIEM system for enhanced security monitoring, alerting, and incident response.
  • Regular Security Scanning of Operational Store Infrastructure: Regularly scan the infrastructure hosting the Operational Store for vulnerabilities and apply necessary patches.
  • Data Retention Policies for Operational Data: Define and implement appropriate data retention policies for operational data, balancing security and compliance requirements.
  • Incident Response Plan for Operational Store Breach: Develop a specific incident response plan to address potential breaches of the Operational Store, including steps for data integrity verification, audit log analysis, and incident investigation.

2.6. Admin UI (Optional, External)

Security Implications:

  • Admin Account Compromise: Compromise of administrator accounts for the Admin UI can grant attackers full control over IdentityServer configuration, leading to widespread security breaches.
  • Web Application Vulnerabilities: The Admin UI itself, being a web application, is susceptible to common web vulnerabilities like XSS, CSRF, SQL injection (if it interacts with a database directly), and insecure authentication/authorization.
  • Configuration Tampering via UI: Vulnerabilities in the Admin UI could allow unauthorized users to bypass authentication or authorization and modify IdentityServer configuration.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Secure Authentication and Authorization for Admin UI: Implement strong authentication mechanisms (MFA strongly recommended) and robust authorization controls for accessing the Admin UI.
  • Web Application Security Best Practices: Develop and maintain the Admin UI following secure coding practices and web application security best practices. Implement protection against common web vulnerabilities (XSS, CSRF, injection attacks, etc.).
  • Regular Security Assessments and Penetration Testing of Admin UI: Conduct regular security assessments and penetration testing specifically targeting the Admin UI to identify and address potential vulnerabilities.
  • Input Validation and Output Encoding in Admin UI: Implement strict input validation for all user inputs in the Admin UI and proper output encoding to prevent injection attacks and XSS vulnerabilities.
  • Secure Communication (HTTPS): Enforce HTTPS for all communication with the Admin UI to protect sensitive data in transit.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Security Training for Admin UI Developers: Provide developers of the Admin UI with security training on secure web development practices and common web application vulnerabilities.
  • Automated Security Scanning of Admin UI: Implement automated security scanning tools (SAST, DAST) to continuously scan the Admin UI codebase for vulnerabilities.
  • Principle of Least Privilege for Admin UI Access: Grant access to the Admin UI only to necessary administrators and with the minimum required privileges.
  • Security Monitoring of Admin UI Activity: Monitor activity within the Admin UI for suspicious actions and unauthorized configuration changes.
  • Consider using a hardened and security-focused Admin UI solution: If using a community-developed or custom-built Admin UI, ensure it has undergone thorough security review and is actively maintained with security updates.

2.7. External Identity Providers (Optional)

Security Implications:

  • Federation Vulnerabilities: Misconfigurations or vulnerabilities in the federation setup with external identity providers can lead to authentication bypasses, account takeover, or information leakage.
  • Trust Exploitation: Attackers might attempt to exploit the trust relationship between IdentityServer and external identity providers to gain unauthorized access.
  • Phishing and Social Engineering: Users might be targeted with phishing attacks or social engineering tactics to compromise their credentials at external identity providers, which could then be used to access applications through IdentityServer.
  • Dependency on External Provider Security: The security of IdentityServer's authentication process becomes dependent on the security posture of the external identity providers. Vulnerabilities in those providers could indirectly impact IdentityServer.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Secure Federation Configuration: Carefully configure federation settings with external identity providers, ensuring proper validation of responses and secure communication protocols (HTTPS).
  • Regular Security Reviews of Federation Integrations: Conduct regular security reviews of the integrations with external identity providers, focusing on configuration, trust relationships, and potential vulnerabilities.
  • User Education on Phishing and Social Engineering: Educate users about phishing attacks and social engineering tactics targeting external identity providers and how to recognize and avoid them.
  • MFA Enforcement (if possible) at External Providers: Encourage or, if possible, enforce MFA at the external identity provider level to enhance the security of federated authentication.
  • Regularly Update Federation Libraries and SDKs: Keep federation libraries and SDKs used for integration with external identity providers up-to-date with the latest security patches.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Implement Robust Input Validation for Federation Responses: Thoroughly validate responses received from external identity providers to prevent injection attacks or manipulation of authentication data.
  • Use Secure Communication Protocols (HTTPS) for Federation: Ensure all communication with external identity providers is over HTTPS to protect data in transit.
  • Monitor Federation Activity for Anomalies: Monitor federation activity for suspicious patterns or anomalies that might indicate attacks or misconfigurations.
  • Establish Clear Trust Boundaries and Responsibilities: Clearly define trust boundaries and responsibilities between IdentityServer and external identity providers in terms of security.
  • Incident Response Plan for Federation-Related Issues: Develop a specific incident response plan to address potential security incidents related to federation with external identity providers.

2.8. Operational Monitoring (Optional)

Security Implications:

  • Exposure of Sensitive Logs: If operational monitoring systems are not properly secured, sensitive logs containing user data, authentication attempts, or error details could be exposed to unauthorized access.
  • Log Tampering: Attackers might attempt to tamper with logs to cover their tracks or hide malicious activity.
  • Monitoring System Compromise: Compromise of the operational monitoring system itself could disrupt security monitoring capabilities and potentially be used to launch further attacks.

Specific Recommendations:

  • Secure Access Control for Monitoring Systems: Implement strict access control mechanisms for operational monitoring systems, ensuring only authorized personnel can access logs and monitoring data.
  • Secure Storage and Transmission of Logs: Store logs securely and transmit them securely to monitoring systems (e.g., using encrypted channels). Consider encryption at rest for sensitive log data.
  • Log Integrity Protection: Implement mechanisms to ensure the integrity of logs, preventing tampering or unauthorized modifications.
  • Regular Security Assessments of Monitoring Infrastructure: Conduct regular security assessments of the infrastructure hosting operational monitoring systems to identify and address potential vulnerabilities.
  • Log Review and Alerting: Establish processes for regular log review and implement alerting mechanisms to detect and respond to security-relevant events identified in the logs.

Mitigation Strategies:

  • Centralized and Secure Logging (SIEM): Utilize a centralized and secure SIEM system for collecting, storing, and analyzing logs from IdentityServer and its components.
  • Principle of Least Privilege for Monitoring Access: Grant access to monitoring systems only to necessary personnel and with the minimum required privileges.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication for Monitoring Access: Enforce MFA for administrator accounts accessing operational monitoring systems.
  • Log Retention Policies: Define and implement appropriate log retention policies, balancing security, compliance, and storage considerations.
  • Incident Response Plan for Monitoring System Compromise: Develop a specific incident response plan to address potential compromises of operational monitoring systems, including steps for restoring monitoring capabilities and investigating potential security breaches that might have been missed due to monitoring disruption.

3. Actionable and Tailored Mitigation Strategies

The recommendations provided above are already tailored to Duende IdentityServer and its components. To further emphasize actionable mitigation strategies, here's a summary focusing on practical steps:

General Actionable Mitigation Strategies for Duende IdentityServer:

  1. Implement a Secure Development Lifecycle (SDLC): Integrate security into every phase of development, from design to deployment.
  2. Regular Security Audits and Penetration Testing: Conduct periodic security audits and penetration tests by qualified security professionals to identify and address vulnerabilities.
  3. Automated Security Scanning: Utilize SAST and DAST tools for continuous vulnerability scanning of IdentityServer and related components (Admin UI, custom extensions).
  4. Dependency Management and Vulnerability Scanning: Implement a robust dependency management process and regularly scan dependencies for known vulnerabilities.
  5. Input Validation and Output Encoding Everywhere: Enforce strict input validation and proper output encoding across all components to prevent injection and XSS attacks.
  6. Strong Cryptography and Secure Key Management: Use strong cryptographic algorithms and implement secure key management practices for signing, encryption, and hashing.
  7. Rate Limiting and DoS Protection: Implement rate limiting on critical endpoints (authentication, token issuance) to mitigate DoS attacks.
  8. Comprehensive Logging and Monitoring (SIEM): Implement centralized logging and monitoring using a SIEM system to detect and respond to security incidents.
  9. Incident Response Plan: Develop and maintain a comprehensive incident response plan specifically tailored to IdentityServer and potential security breaches.
  10. Security Training for Development and Operations Teams: Provide regular security training to developers, operations teams, and administrators on secure coding practices, IdentityServer security best practices, and incident response procedures.
  11. Principle of Least Privilege: Apply the principle of least privilege for access control across all components, configurations, and administrative interfaces.
  12. Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) Enforcement: Enforce MFA for administrator accounts and strongly encourage/enforce MFA for user accounts.
  13. Regular Security Updates and Patching: Keep Duende IdentityServer, its dependencies, and the underlying infrastructure up-to-date with the latest security patches.
  14. Secure Configuration Management: Implement secure configuration management practices, including version control, access control, and auditing of configuration changes.
  15. HTTPS Everywhere: Enforce HTTPS for all communication with IdentityServer and related components to protect data in transit.

Specific Actionable Mitigation Examples:

  • For User Store Credential Compromise: Implement Argon2id for password hashing, enforce MFA, and implement account lockout with increasing backoff times.
  • For Configuration Store Unauthorized Changes: Implement RBAC for configuration management, enable audit logging for all configuration changes, and encrypt sensitive configuration data at rest.
  • For Token Store Token Theft: Encrypt tokens at rest in the Token Store, implement token revocation mechanisms, and use short-lived access tokens.
  • For Admin UI Web Vulnerabilities: Conduct regular penetration testing of the Admin UI, implement a WAF in front of the Admin UI, and enforce strong authentication (MFA) for admin access.
  • For External Identity Provider Federation Vulnerabilities: Regularly review federation configurations, implement robust input validation for federation responses, and educate users about phishing attacks targeting external providers.

By implementing these tailored and actionable mitigation strategies, organizations can significantly enhance the security posture of their Duende IdentityServer deployments and protect their applications and users from potential threats. Continuous security monitoring, regular assessments, and proactive security practices are crucial for maintaining a strong security posture over time.